Jewelry Stores near Pewaukee, WI

26 locations found near Pewaukee

“This place is awesome. Recently got a nice watch as a gift and was nervous to resize the band myself - Jeff was able to help me get it right super quickly. Highly recommend!”

4.9 Superb101 Reviews

“This place is amazing. I’ve found so many treasures here. The pricing is reasonable. The staff is super and you never know what you’re going to find! Great store!”

4.4 Superb42 Reviews

“Kesslers is the absolute best! We had the best experiences from my fiancé getting my engagement ring there to both of us getting our wedding bands too. Always a smooth and positive experience and it’s amazing being able to take my rings in at any time for cleaning, resizing, soldering. I would recommend them 100% for any jewelry needs!”

4.9 Superb255 Reviews

“Great experience! Super helpful in taking care of an old watchband for my mother. Also helped me navigate getting my ring re-sized. Can’t be wait until it is done!”

4.9 Superb192 Reviews

“Sara from Kesslers did a wonderful job from beginning to end. She understood our vision when helping us create a “new” wedding ring. The new ring literally brought tears to my eyes. Sara was even able to expedite the process and I was able to receive my new ring before we left town for a long weekend. Wonderful experience! Totally recommend Kesslers!”

4.9 Superb176 Reviews

“10/10 store. So nice, welcoming and everything in between. I needed to fix my necklace chain and they did it for free, served me water and made sure I felt right at home. Are you kidding? So awesome. Will be back 100%!”

4.8 Superb208 Reviews

“Love this shop! I feel inspired when I look around at all the beautiful beads. The owner and staff are so supportive in the way they encourage you to try new things and help when you're confused on a step in the process. The kits are fun and easy since they include all that's needed. Have been going here for decades.”

4.9 Superb85 Reviews

“I brought my husbands watch in for repair.There were quite a bit of scratches on the case, from years ago. It also needed a new battery.Dominic buffed all of the scratches out.It looks like it did when I purchased it over 30 years ago.Our anniversary is next week. I plan to surprise him with his newly polished beautiful watch. So he can wear it on our travels.I will always bring his watch here.Thank you so much Dominic, your work is impressive, and greatly appreciated.All of the people were friendly and accommodating at the Craig Husar Fine Diamonds & Jewelry Designs.”

4.8 Superb171 Reviews

“10/10 recommend! I would give them more than five stars if I could. Sedona was so sweet and did such a fantastic job. She is so patient and helpful and walks you through every step of the way. I got my nose pierced with no true idea of what I was looking for in jewelry. She spent time showing me her favorites and recommendations. I couldn’t decide on placement, and she went above and beyond to help me visualize (the dot on your nose is harder to visualize than you anticipate!) Super clean and cute shop too. I’ll be back if I decide to pursue any more piercings!”

4.8 Superb85 Reviews

“I’m beyond grateful for running across Mid Continental Gems. My mother in law was looking to get some old rings fixed that had a lot of sentimental value. Other jewelers I took it to quoted me and arm and a leg. Mid Continetal was beyond reasonable and you could feel the small business family owned feel. The care and respect they have for each individual piece that they work is greatly appreciated. I received the two rings back and couldn’t even tell where they were originally broken. Will definitely be coming here with all of my jewelry needs!”

5 Superb58 Reviews

“Great, friendly, helpful customer service. Brought in a silver necklace with a ring on it that I’ve worn every day for probably 6 years. They cleaned and buffed it so well that it looks brand new. I highly recommend taking your jewelry here.”

4.8 Superb54 Reviews

“Absolutely love this store and how they support so many local women owned small businesses. I am however always disappointed in customer service. The staff always seems to be bothered, doesn't welcome you or even smile. It would be such a better experience if they did.”

4.7 Superb92 Reviews

“I had 2 rings that I wanted to sell and I was very apprehensive to even go to them due to the experience I had at Walsh Jewelers. I was pleasantly surprised with the amount they offered (which was well over what I was offered by Walsh). I will definitely be a returning customer.”

4.9 Superb55 Reviews

“Posting from Jean N.Walsh is now my “go to” jewelry store. I turned my old, unwanted jewelry into cash, purchased lab created diamond earrings, had ring repair work done, and appraisals. Their personalized customer service is exceptional.”

4.8 Superb70 Reviews

“Frank, Sheila's jewelry repair person is the bomb! And Sheila's wonderful too! I guarantee you if Frankie is fixing it it's going to be done well and it's going to be done right ??”

4.8 Superb40 Reviews

“Mike and Kimberly deliver again!. Exceptional service and very friendly people. They made me a hero to my wife. Happy wife happy life :-). Thank you again both for making the impossible happen!!!. A++++ to infinity and beyond!”

4.7 Superb60 Reviews

“Donna and Monica and all the beautiful ladies that work here are so friendly and helpful and were patient with me as I took a lot of time to pick out my beautiful ring! I’m a loyal customer for life.”

4.6 Superb109 Reviews

“Bought my wife’s ring over a decade ago and the jeweler that we had the “lifetime” warranty through went out of business. Took the ring to a big box jeweler and they said they couldn’t touch it because it wasn’t their ring. Walked into Powers and was quickly greeted by Keith. After explaining my situation that the main stone had fallen out and I was out of options, he swiftly described the steps needed to repair the ring. The work was done in a timely fashion and I felt the price was extremely fair. Happy wife…happy life. They will have all of my future business.”

4.9 Superb31 Reviews

“Super friendly and always willing to help. Walked in the other today with some of my coins and got an appraisal right away for free. No appointment or anything, then I tried to pay for the appraisal and wouldn't let me. Great place, will be back again.”

4.6 Superb89 Reviews

“Unreal, great service. I brought in a ring that my wife got from her friends. The centerpiece had fallen out. He repaired it in 5 minutes right there in the store! I never expected to have it done the same day, let alone 5 minutes! Thank you, I won’t go anywhere else for future repairs.”

4.7 Superb62 Reviews

“An extraordinary little gem! Stones, crystals, pendants, tons of string and wire, tools.... Everything needed for jewelry making. Unfortunately, they sell lampwork beads and a few tools of the trade but no glass rods. Wonderful staff. Still 5 stars.”

4.7 Superb77 Reviews

“Stopped into the store and we ended up making two separate purchases. Very nice store, the sales people were very friendly. Our second purchase we were helped by the store manager Steve. He worked with us and gave us a great deal on a necklace. We will definitely purchase from them again.”

4.8 Superb72 Reviews

“I had 2 custom rings done by Tobin Jewelers New Berlin and they did an outstanding job. Rob and Raine were a pleasure to work with. They walked me through the process and kept me informed each step of the way. They listened to what I wanted and didn’t try to change my mind. They made the rings exactly like I wanted. I couldn’t be more pleased with my rings and how I was treated. If you have jewelry needs do yourself a favor and visit Tobin Jewelers. You won’t be disappointed!”

4.6 Superb57 Reviews

“Great service and great selection. If they don't have what you are looking for, they will find it for you. Love the team here and would recommend them for wedding rings to everyday jewelry purchases.”

4.4 Superb49 Reviews

“Sophie was wonderful, she listened and helped me find the perfect ring for me. Just the fact that she was able to guide my husband in the right direction for understanding our options showed me how well she has mastered her craft in helping people.
I highly recommend giving Rogers and Hollands a chance in helping you and your jewelry needs. And if Sophie is there that day, that's a double positive recommendation. ???✨️?”

4.4 Superb95 Reviews

“Purchased a set of silver hoops at the location in Mall of America back in February. The other day, I lost one of them. I went to this store in the Brookfield Corners and was helped right away by Allyssa M. She was super friendly and was able to find the same pair within seconds. She noticed I had just purchased them within the year, so she replaced my set for free! Thank you so much for the great customer service! I really appreciated it!”

4.2 Good48 Reviews