Jewelry Stores near New Berlin, WI

30 locations found near New Berlin
View Map

“Great family owned business. Always willing to go above and beyond. Great pricing and selection on jewelry they can get.Can also always count on them for finding that special or custom piece of jewelry that big box stores cannot. Great atmosphere always kind and welcoming. My jeweler for life thanks for helping me find my necklace.”

4.8 Superb63 Reviews

“They’ve been nothing but helpful and honest. You can’t ask for a better experience with the service and staff provided at Tobin Jewelers. I’ll continue to come for all of my jewelry needs!”

4.4 Superb41 Reviews

“Have used Haase Jewelers for a number of years, mostly for resizing and repairs. My family and I trust Haase to take great care of our heirloom pieces and make sure they are fixed up and ready to be fully appreciated (and I know my mom has found a few new pieces to add to her collection along the way too!).Even during this busy, crazy Christmas season, Haase’s wonderful staff worked their magic. There was a bit of confusion regarding when my rings would be fixed, but Vince and staff took great care to make sure I’d have these in time for Christmas regardless. Thank you so much for yet another wonderful experience and my family and I will continue to recommend you to other family and friends!”

4.9 Superb108 Reviews

“Excellent service! I needed a ring resized that has a fossil in it and another store had told me it couldn’t be done. Paul’s Jewelers had it resized and back to me in under a week. I will definitely be a repeat customer.”

4.9 Superb92 Reviews

“Where do I start? The level of treatment I received from the second I walked in to the moment I picked up my ring was unparalleled to anything I've ever experienced. Everyone there went above and beyond and it was so natural! Anyone looking for any kind of jewelry should go here. Thank you again Harry for taking care of me and my future wife, I will never forget it!!”

4.9 Superb87 Reviews

“I have been in search of a skilled jeweler who can assist me with creating custom ring designs using my late mother's jewelry. I recently visited another jewelry store where I was quite disappointed with the level of service I received. However, my sister highly recommended the jewelry center, prompting me to give it a try. I am sincerely grateful that I did. From the moment I stepped in, I was warmly greeted by Keo, a courteous and helpful woman who was able to bring my ideas to fruition. She handled my cherished jewelry pieces with the utmost care and respect, displaying extensive knowledge in the field of jewelry. The entire process was truly enjoyable thanks to her expertise. While I am not typically an avid collector of fine jewelry, I am confident that my next purchase will be from Keo.”

5 Superb57 Reviews

“When my ring needed repair after years of wear, the process was fast and easy. I was in and out in a matter of minutes and it was ready far earlier than expected. And they covered everything, fully standing behind the product -- decades later.”

4.8 Superb126 Reviews

“Sarah was extremely friendly & helpful! My account goes back to Shaw's Jewelers in 1996 & she was able to find what I was looking for regarding my wedding set. I will definitely be back to work with her!”

4.9 Superb69 Reviews

“Love this shop! I feel inspired when I look around at all the beautiful beads. The owner and staff are so supportive in the way they encourage you to try new things and help when you're confused on a step in the process. The kits are fun and easy since they include all that's needed. Have been going here for decades.”

4.8 Superb84 Reviews

“This is the place you need to be. Craig and his team did a fabulous job with assisting us with your our purchase of a stunning ring. The quality and clarity of our ring is outstanding. Thank you for making this process relaxing and enjoyable.”

4.9 Superb48 Reviews

“Have always seen this shop, but this was my 1st time going in, and I wish I had gone in sooner! For as small as the shop is, it is packed full and has basically everything.”

4.7 Superb111 Reviews

“I brought my ring in to be resized and was quoted about a 2 week turnaround. Dropped off on Saturday and picked up the following Friday and was shocked it was done in less than a week and in perfect condition. I’m so happy my ring fits again and that it was returned back to me so fast. Super helpful, nice staff! Will certainly be back.”

4.8 Superb61 Reviews

“The best customer service there is, always a wonderful experience! My favorite place to refer to friends and family! We love sending people to Kelly for engagement ring shopping”

4.8 Superb56 Reviews

“Great place to find some local craftsmanship, from jewelry and plants to antiques and handmade decor. I love the selection of local vendors available and the workers are always kind. Make sure to check this place out on Saturdays this winter and you'll be offered complimentary hot cocoa/cider and cookies!”

4.7 Superb89 Reviews

“Vicki Z. was AMAZING! She was very patient and helpful.. took her time to help me find what I was looking for. She was extremely personable and kind. I will definitely return!!”

4.7 Superb75 Reviews

“I have definitely found a piercing shop I’ll be returning to for all my piercing needs! Lexie was absolutely amazing, so professional & friendly. She answered all of my questions and made me feel so comfortable! I completely recommend this place to anyone with anxiety, or anyone looking for a good atmosphere for their next piercing. It was also super clean & organized. She even showed me physical proof that my jewelry was sterilized. It literally could not have been a better septum piercing experience for me!”

4.7 Superb63 Reviews

“Larry was great at working with me to customize an engagement ring that my girlfriend will love. We sat down and discussed all the things she would want and all the things she doesn’t want. They didn’t have any in stock that were what I was looking for, but he had one custom done in a few weeks that was everything we discussed!”

4.7 Superb57 Reviews

“Very honest man! He explains the entire buying process and his calculations. He Makes sure you are content and reassured that selling here is the best deal. Highly recommend!”

4.6 Superb73 Reviews

“My husband designed my engagement ring with the help of John and he was attentive and responsive throughout the whole process. We got our wedding bands through Lampone Jewelers as well, and from picking them out to making sure they fit perfectly and were polished for our big day, they were wonderful to work with. If you want to work with the most friendly, attentive, family owned business, go to Lampone Jewelers!”

4.7 Superb42 Reviews

“I needed a basic repair done on a necklace I had purchased elsewhere. Magpie was very reasonably priced for the repair and you can't tell at all that it had been fixed. Would recommend!”

4.7 Superb40 Reviews

“Robert Haack is my “go-to” Diamond and Jewelry place…period. My wife and I have been shopping at Robert Haack for the last 12 years. Their service and quality are unsurpassed in Wisconsin. Talk to Leslie at the Layton Ave location. You will not be disappointed and you won’t shop anywhere else going forward!”

4.5 Superb137 Reviews

“This is the best exotic dance wear store I have ever been to! Y’all this is the only place I’ll be going for all my dancing & rave needs. Straight up so much variety to try on, and it is ALL quality!! I got outfits that I hadn’t seen anywhere else that were so cool. I would recommend to ANYONE who is looking to buy exotic dancer wear!Plus by coming here you can support a black woman owned store soooo what are you doin reading this review?? Call and see her availability!!”

4.9 Superb22 Reviews

“My 11 year old took some coins in to have them looked at. Ambrea and Joel were so nice and welcoming. Ambrea took the time to listen and then also gave him some pointers on what to look for in the future. Definitely would go back.”

4.6 Superb44 Reviews

“Ellen was fantastic! I really appreciated how personable she was. She remembered what I wanted and was nice enough to keep me in mind for a mint green DateJust. She has my business from now on! Thanks Ellen!”

4.7 Superb29 Reviews

“I love this place! My husband got my wedding/engagement rings resized here. The quality of work, speed of service, customer service and price were all outstanding. I've never been to a jewelry business that was so warm and thorough.”

4.8 Superb18 Reviews

“Gorgeous work! I have gone there 3 times now with somewhat of an idea of what I wanted. Jim and his son, Brad helped me refine the idea and what they came up with was amazing. The quality of gems is of high value but for very fair prices. You can't go wrong! This is the Barnes on Greenfield Ave in West Allis.”

4.9 Superb14 Reviews

“One of the best experiences that I have had at a jewelry shop. I need to have my watched fixed and the work was completed while I waited. The service was top notch and the cost was so reasonable. I would definitely recommend this jewelry shop. His honesty and integrity are the best. This will be the first place I will come if I need to buy jewelry or get it repaired!”

5 Superb10 Reviews

“STOPPED AT HOLLANDS FIRST AND THEN VISITED TWO OTHER JEWELRY STORES.WENT BACK TO HOLLANDS WHERE THE BEST SERVICE AND CHOICE FOR WHAT MY GIRLFRIEND AND I WERE LOOKING FOR WAS. VERY GLAD THAT WE CHOSE HOLLAND”

4.6 Superb21 Reviews

“Kelly was AMAZING! He took his time and was so kind and helped me pick out the perfect gift for my husband. I had my wild toddler with me and he played and asked her questions to help keep her entertained so I could focus and look for what means something to me and what would be perfect! I even had time to find a nice necklace for myself. Wonderful selection with great prices. Thanks again Kelly :)”

4.4 Superb52 Reviews

“I met with a couple of jewelers and a lot of them kept telling me how much I should spend and how the ring should look. I reached out to Dean at Shallow Jewelers with some ideas and the experience was immediately different! He was not pushy and took everything I had to say to heart and helped me get exactly what I had in mind! Shallow Jewelers is the place to go 10/10!”

4.7 Superb14 Reviews