Pennsylvania Macaroni Company is a premier Italian specialty food operation and a legendary gem in Pittsburgh's Strip District. It is a classic example of a family-run business with great people, now in its third generation. The store boasts an overwhelming and excellent selection of over 5,000 specialty products, making it the best anywhere in Pittsburgh for authentic Italian ingredients. Customers will find everything needed for an authentic Italian dish, including a vast deli with hundreds of fine cheeses, cured meats, olives, freshly made pasta, fresh bread, olive oils, tomatoes, and more. The efficient and helpful counter staff are top notch, providing knowledgeable service and slicing cold cuts with extra care. However, experiences can be mixed, with some checkout staff described as rude, high-strung, sassy, or impatient, which can lead to baffling interactions and occasional outbursts. Despite this, the overall experience is good, with the quality and variety of specialty items consistently praised. Shoppers are advised to focus on the unique specialty items not found in normal grocery stores, as prices are higher for standard goods. The store is often packed with people, and visitors should be prepared to exceed their budget because everything is so good.
Great selection of everything. Unfortunately, they only sell cheese by the block and won't slice it for you.
September 2024
Their hours make it really difficult for me to ever make it over there. I wish they were open later than 4pm at least one weekday so I could stop by on my way home from work. Great selection tho
May 2024
Best place for cheese, pasta, & spices. Charged 25 cents for a flimsy paper bag after spending $134 on items.
