Grocery Stores near Shelter Island, NY

16 locations found near Shelter Island

“This is such a funny/lovely little grocery.It reminded me of the small town grocery store from the 2007 flop, "The Mist." It also has shockingly good music playing throughout the store. I found myself dancing several times in the aisles only to catch of a glimpse of several other shoppers doing the same. What a riot!”

4.1 Good46 Reviews

“Made a quick stop here for an early lunch on the way to the Orient Point Ferry. What a nice quaint place with real friendly staff! I had the Quinoa Salad which was wonderful as it was freshly made with excellent greens and a light salad dressing. Nice quantity and reasonably priced. My wife had the Ham, Brie and Apple sandwich which she thoroughly enjoyed. Highly recommend this place.”

4.8 Superb100 Reviews

“Love this place. Perfect to stop and grab a little something when going to visit someone’s house and you don’t want to arrive empty handed. Fabulous steaks as well and the chicken burgers are a must.”

5 Superb8 Reviews

“Love Fit Food!! Our own little Whole Foods!! Matt has competitive pricing besides being a great guy!! Ask for something he may not have and he will do his best to get it for you.Please give him your support so we can all benefit.”

5 Superb15 Reviews

“Wide selection of common and obscure foods. The wholesome staff frequently choose to go out of their way to help you, and in my experience the other customers are very friendly as well.”

4.2 Good88 Reviews

“Well I went here to get some fill in foods such gf breads, crackers, tea, coffee, and juice. The store is labeled well with the products in each isle. The store is clean free of odors hazardous materials”

4.2 Good91 Reviews

“For a small store they have a big selection and have great service. If they don't have it ask them and they will try to order it for you. They even have imported DePalma pursuit”

4.1 Good82 Reviews

“Best green juice! They fill to the brim (I had taken a couple sips in the pic) and are well priced. The ones at Citarella cost the same and they are pre made and taste like garbage. Love this spot everyone is so sweet.”

4.1 Good59 Reviews

“Superbly stocked supermarket, especially considering its location. Excellent produce department with lots of local items available and good (not outstanding) selection of Latin produce available. Helpful, responsive staff who clearly care about the store. We're really lucky.”

3.9 Good86 Reviews

“I have been a huge fan of this shop for more years than I can remember, and in all those years, I have never been disappointed. The premium, extra-virgin, olive oil oils, and their natural balsamic vinegar are beyond compare. Not only are they perfect for personal use, but these oils and vinegars make perfect gifts whether it’s for a special occasion or just dropping by for a visit … definitely more long lasting and more appreciative than a cake or a box of cookies.”

3.9 Good41 Reviews

“Great little health food shop to go and get your slightly more healthy Fixin‘s. Everything from chocolate to soap. You might even be able to eat the soap…Standard East End pricing that’s why it’s got four stars for me instead of five.”

3.8 Good52 Reviews

“Convenient small grocer nestled in a residential area close to Long Beach, Noyak, and Sag Harbor. Fresh produce, good deli counter with prepared dishes as well. Offers customers pantry staples and baked goods too.”

3.8 Good91 Reviews

“This place is expensive, but compared to the other supermarkets. it is extremely cheap l o l. All the vegetables are always fresh and the same with the dairy and the deli. This is probably one of the better king kullens. More adults tend to work at this location and not kids. Which makes the place a more professional calm and clean environment. The lines here are never too long and they have a self check out station.”

3.8 Good117 Reviews

“Great grab and go lunch options (salads, wraps, smoothies, etc.). Some of the grocery items can get expensive, but if you need something specific (vegan, GF, etc.) you’ll likely find a brand you know and love.The vegan broccoli salad was delicious!”

3.5 Good49 Reviews

“Best pies anywhere. Prepared food at the Red Horse is great. The baked clams, empanadas, salads are all top notch. Though it’s hard to walk out of there without spending at least $100 every time. I realize it’s the Hamptons, but prices are still a bit high. Not the best spot for groceries, definitely worth it for the prepared foods.”

3.2 Average61 Reviews

“Wayside Market is one of the must-stop eating places on the North Fork. The owners, Pasquale and his daughter Isabella, are truly wonderful and caring people, as is their team of great people who work there. The food is always fresh and delicious. One of the rarities in this day and age, is a family owned and run deli that still makes food on their menu from scratch and by hand with a lot of love and care. And you can taste the difference BIG time. New Yorkers can be a tough crowd to please and there's a reason why they have so many regular customers who love Wayside Market. Many people don't realize what it takes to run a business, especially in New York, where the costs are so much higher than in many other parts of the country. Come hungry and you'll leave happy. I always do. Looking forward to my next visit to Wayside Market! Best wishes to everyone...Robert W”

3 Average138 Reviews