Pet Stores near Port Jefferson, NY

16 locations found near Port Jefferson

“My dogs are the pickiest of picky when it comes to food but I went there today and just wow night and day my dogs are eating it and they are happy and I'm happy”

5 Superb36 Reviews

“This is a lovely and friendly business. It's a wonderful place to bring your furbaby because the owner truly cares and loves the pets and cares about her customers. Support your small businesses! The care you get here cannot be emulated by ANY web based stores. The variety is wonderful and lots of unique items. Will keep on coming here!”

5 Superb108 Reviews

“An old town favorite that has been there for generations. Very nice to have a mom & pop store with such personable people still in business. Great selection of salt & fresh water fish and more. If anything, check out their axolotl babies! So cool.”

4.6 Superb125 Reviews

“I go to pet supplies plus Smithtown at least once a week to get my dog food, treats and crickets. It’s always a comfortable and happy environment. The staff is always kind and ready to help if needed. There’s one specific employee, Nick, that I really have to mention, because he really just puts a smile on my face every time I’m there. If I’m not smiling when I walk in the store.. I’m definitely
Smiling when I leave. He is always SO kind and his energy is unmatched! So, thank you Nick, and thank you PSP for being the best pet store in town!<3”

4.5 Superb135 Reviews

“This place was amazing. Answered the phone professionally, confirmed they had what I needed. When I arrived, they showed me where the bag of dog food was and carried it to the register, then carried it to my car. It was my first time here and I am so impressed. Going back to this store instead of the big chain I used to go to. Thank you so much!”

4.5 Superb104 Reviews

“I love pet supply plus. They are friendly and great customer service. Their loyalty program is worth it. Especially if you have a return. My only thing is that they are the only ones that carry wx low pherious on the shelf. Because they have the in gravy in stock they had not ordered the puree. They were out of stock for 2 weeks, when I called and inquired they said that they can't garentee it will be there for another two weeks. Forcing my hand to order online. If they have what you are looking for, they are great. I recommend checking out their website for stock before you head down.”

4.3 Superb153 Reviews

“For a chain store, this one outshines most others. Always clean and well stocked with personable people. They also have a dog trainer (Jade) that is full of knowledge and great to work with. There always seems to be a sale going on as well. I am big into aquariums and this store does not disappoint.”

4.2 Good148 Reviews

“I’ve been a customer with Farmingville Feed for approximately 6 months. I use them to get my mini-dachshund groomed every few months. I have always been comfortable with each grooming session, and have always been pleased with how my pup looks. Laurie is friendly, attentive, and always handles my dog with care. Laurie’s grooming is always done efficiently, and my pup looks adorable and smells amazing every time! Overall, I would highly recommend Farmingville Feed to anyone in need of a professional pet grooming service that is reliable and top-notch!”

4.7 Superb57 Reviews

“I am giving them 4 1/2. Stars !!!!!!!!!! I have been in the store about 20 times since I adopted my Lab puppy in march of 23. Mostly because they have a large variety of dog products, food, bully sticks toys etc. . Their prices are a bit higher or equal to that of the chain stores. But they carry so many items in stock on their shelves it's worth it. Example! My pup is a chewer, loves bully sticks, they have them in all sizes, shapes imaginable including a three foot bully stick. You're lucky if you can find any in the big box stores without ordering on line. I mostly shop in the Selden store, and have been helped by many different employees, all of them have been extremely polite and courteous every time. Never had a problem with any of their employees. Just wanted to mention this because of all the negative reviews on their employees.”

4.1 Good93 Reviews

“I have visited First Flight Exotic Birds several times and the staff is always very personable and knowledgeable. Everything is reasonably priced and the store is always kept clean. I highly recommend this store.”

4.7 Superb58 Reviews

“I took our goldendoodle Snickerdoodle to your lake Grove location for grooming. Vincent is ABSOLUTELY AMAZING!! I asked him to shave her for the summer. He left a poof poof on her tail that I am so in love with!! Next time I'm going to ask him to give her a mowhawk! I can't wait for her hair to grow again to see Vincent's creativity!!”

3.8 Good187 Reviews

“It waa my 1st time in that Pet Smart & The customer I asked for help to locate what i was looking for were more friendly and helpful than the staff that I had to track down and call to twice brfore I got him to finally help me.”

3.8 Good146 Reviews

“We need to support this establishment. Otherwise you will no longer be able to see the items you want to buy except for in a photo on the internet. Every chance you get... DO NOT BUY FROM THE AMAZON MONOPOLY.”

3.7 Good172 Reviews

“In a world where it’s all about money & business, this store is an exemption. Giving 10 stars for the owner who took his time to show us around & gave us a neon tetra glow fish for free to “start us on the right track” Prices compared to Petco & Petsmart are waaay cheaper. And the variety of fishes there is in the store was a plus! We will definitely be back for future needs.”

3.8 Good129 Reviews

“I adopted Molly from Long Island Feline Adoption Center in January 2023 and Im glad i did and its been nothing but joy and love ever since. Molly is my first cat and I definitely was a bit nervous as I only had dogs previously and I knew the breeds were definitely different. As soon as I arrived at Feline Adoption Center Cheryll took her time to get to know me and my living situation and what I was looking for and matched me with Molly. I came in on a Monday and visited every day that week and went home with Molly that Saturday. Molly is such a sweet, beautiful and well behaved cat. Im so lucky to have her and Im so thankful to Cheryll for matching us Molly is what was missing from my life. Molly is so comfortable in her new home and its only been 5 months and I know that love and joy is only going to continue to grow as I hope she lives a long & happy life. Thank you so much to Cheryll and Long Island Feline Adoption Center!!! You are the BEST!!”

4.3 Superb26 Reviews

“i just bought a tarantula here today and i had such a great experience! a very nice and funny lady, jackie helped me and she was so kind. she helped me get everything i needed and even recommended me many things. she helped me get a vet & helped me choose which food. & she did a spectacular job taking out the tarantula for me which can be very scary her and sam were great workers and they deserve a raise! thank you so much”

1.7 Poor29 Reviews