“I'm so happy this store has it's own page to leave a review on! This is one of the stores that makes Smith Haven Mall stand out to us as better than most.I've been going to Smith Haven mall for years and this has always been one of my family's go-to stores. The prices either match normal retail, or are BETTER. Anime, pop culture, NECA, FNAF, Music, rare DVD's - We are always able to find items here that are hard to get online. We've gotten a lot of rare and cool things from this store.They also have a great selection of candy as well that we like to buy when we have movie nights!”
11AM - 8PM
5507 Nesconset Hwy # 12A, Mt Sinai“This place was my 1st experience with buying wacky tabaki LEGALLY (?). The gentleman who helped me was pretty awesome. Super kind and knowledgeable. DIDN'T try to get me to buy more expensive items. Was so genuine. Loved it.”
9:30AM - 9:30PM
1851 Sunrise Hwy, Bay Shore“Five below is a fun store. Great variety of products. Some things are overpriced, like $5 for a bouncy ball. Remember when they were 89 cents. Overall though you get some good deals”
“Though the store in general has a lot going on, it was clean, and organized. Only con is the fact of Self checkout. It takes away people interaction and the whole purpose of going to a store is to buy products and connect with people. Self- checkout eliminates that factor.”
“Five below East setuaket
I’m pasting this comment from my Girlfriend to you guys as she can’t login using her credentials.
To Five Below
I went shopping at five below in East Setuaket. Around 6pm on October 3, 2024, the was a man Asssociate and a Manager who both were very professional and friendly.The Manager helped me scan my items and so so caring and had great communication skills.Both Associates are a true asset to your company.I was telling her about my gift card I got today during my Chemotherapy treatment at the cancer center.
The manager is a real caring compassion person.I Love Five Below store especially this store.
Danielle”
9:30AM - 9:30PM
787 Middle Country Rd #17C, Selden“On October 20, 2023 Five Below had their grand opening in Selden. The same parking lot as Shoprite and the Post Office. You can find a large array of stuff. However, not much I have a use for. Today was my second time I went to check out the Christmas items but again I was not impressed. What I noticed is the presence of many tweens and teens looking for a bargain. Most items are less then $5. The youngins were grooving to the music while enjoying their shopping experience. Five Below has a decent inventory of tee shirts & other clothing, beauty products, party goods, holiday decorations, gifts, arts & crafts, toys, games, books , candy, cell phone accessories and so on and so on. Although I don't see myself purchasing much here I would definitely consider getting a few gift cards and gift bags. It was nice to see the young population shopping comfortable for things they can afford and connecting with their friends. Best wishes Five Below, I wish you much success.!”
“OMG! I was surprised by its amazing stock in all areas. The prices are so competitive, the atmosphere is so quiet, and the customer service is superb! I recommend this store to anyone who can save some money!”
“It's 5 below they have all the stuff you need from the dollar store just higher quality not that it's life changing but definitely worth a visit we go here often. They carry alot of Japanese candy and soda. The tech options here (chargers etc) is good for the price. Dont expect the highest quality. Lower your expectations and you won't be disappointed”