Jewelry Stores near Islip, NY

30 locations found near Islip

“I’ve been going to Mazza for years, from the staff, to the quality, the experience has been perfection. Besides all of the beautiful jewelry myself and friends have purchased at Mazza over the years, my husband recently got my engagement ring, and our wedding bands from there. I’m absolutely obsessed with our rings. Thank you Mazza!!”

4.5 Superb27 Reviews

“A great find. Brought in 3 watches I thought were hopeless and Ricky had them up-and-running in an hour. Great pricing. And a shop filled with top brand jewelry & watches. Definitely be back.”

4.9 Superb169 Reviews

“The prices were respectable and frankly I can't complain about them. The service was STELLAR, and almost seemed free if you consider the usual retail prices for silver.TLDR: They shortened a chain to my perfect length, made a bracelet from the spare links, and made a new bail for my pendant, making no fuss about any of it whatsoever throughout the whole process. And I can't emphasize enough how reasonable their prices are if you need any work done.Steve was beyond helpful. (I'm pretty sure Amanda) was lovely and helped me find the perfect chain, but it was way longer than I wanted. Not only did Steve shorten the chain for me, they are also turning the spare length into a bracelet! Steve even measured the chain on me to make sure that the length I wanted matched the length I asked for. On top of that, I have a pendant that's incredibly important that I wanted to put on one of their chains, but the bail was beaten to heck and way too small. They added a new, sturdy bail and attached it for me.All in all, two sterling silver chains, a bail, shortening a chain, and putting a rush on all of it only cost me a couple hundred. STELLAR service, beautiful people, and I intend to go there for ALL of my jewelry needs because of those two. (Not just to purchase, but also maintenance and miscellaneous work)”

4.9 Superb66 Reviews

“This store has some really cute pieces and I love how friendly the staff is. Jen and Olivia were a wonderful help to me while shopping with my kids! My daughters also managed to find a little cute tea set! We’ll be back!”

4.9 Superb42 Reviews

“We visited Devin Jewelers yesterday for the first time in our 8 years living in Northport. The store was immaculate and inviting and nicely appointed, and Tina could not have been more warm, receptive, and helpful.We brought in 3 wristwatches requiring battery replacements and she told us it would take about 15 minutes to be complete.To our delight, all was done in minutes by a young man who brought them out to the countertop, and we were charged a very modest and fair price for the task.Devin Jewelers is certainly a shop to visit for your jewelry, gift and repair needs. They have beautiful pieces, and nicely designed store, and wonderful people there to serve you, right down Larkfield Road in Northport.”

4.8 Superb90 Reviews

“LOVE the new location!! Same great Guru’s selection — powerful crystals, breezy summer dresses, everything you need to feel (and look!) more calm, centered, and beautiful. Definitely don’t miss stopping into this special gem of a store ✨”

4.8 Superb66 Reviews

“I recently purchased an engagement ring at D’Ore for my now fiancée. The entire experience was amazing! All of the employees, especially Donna, were so knowledgeable, friendly, and professional. I will be recommending D’Ore to everyone I know looking for quality jewelry!”

4.8 Superb75 Reviews

“Recently I decided to redeem my coins at CCJ in Smithtown. I met with Mike and he was extremely likeable, courteous, and knowledgeable. It was my first experience involving this type of transaction. Mike's personality and expertise made this an informative and pleasurable experience. I can honestly recommend Mike and CCJ in Smithtown to anyone interested in exchanging coins.Bob Newman”

5 Superb61 Reviews

“Each and every time I shop at this lovely jewelry store, I leave happier and happier. The staff is professional, kind, courteous, and willing to go that extra mile for the consumer. Kelly is delightful and accommodating. I highly recommend this fine jewelry store for your best shopping experience.”

4.8 Superb118 Reviews

“I bought a beautiful diamond ring that in the end was custom made. I spent quite a while there and the staff was so kind and patient through the whole process. I highly recommend Squires!”

4.8 Superb88 Reviews

“Such a beautiful store! So many unique things, great for finding gifts. And the Christmas store! You have a fantastic buyer who has elegant taste. Such fun doing my Christmas shopping!”

4.8 Superb74 Reviews

“Arianna was amazing. Her service was impeccable. The store was extremely clean very friendly atmosphere location was easy to get in and out and they had everything that I needed. It’s a one stop shop for all your joy needs. I highly recommend visiting this location.”

4.7 Superb82 Reviews

“Just had the best experience on a whim! I've been meaning to sell some gold, and found The Gold Source right around the block. As soon as I walked in, I was greeted right away. LaKisha and Stanley took extra care in assessing my jewelry (which I loved). Both owners really light up a room- I am VERY happy the price. If you've been waiting on selling some jewelry, I can honestly say this is the best place to go for the best price you'll get. Thank you so much :)”

5 Superb46 Reviews

“Great Antique store. There is different vendors inside with tons of Antiques and Collectibles, with toys and household things. Prices vary. But a kool place to get a few things or just browse.”

4.8 Superb28 Reviews

“Went in on a Sunday to replace a watch battery, Addy was very professional, tended to my watch needs and no charge, I did bring the battery. My new go to Jeweler in Smithtown, Thank you.”

4.8 Superb62 Reviews

“Incredible service from Hersel and Dan. It's not every day that you find a place that has beautiful jewelry and their level of customer service. I've been a customer for over 10 years and highly recommend them!”

5 Superb14 Reviews

“An amazing and fun place....my wife and I have been coming here for years and there is a huge selection for every taste and a very friendly staff. In the warmer weather they also host an outdoor flea market on a number of Sundays which is always fun and well-attended.”

4.6 Superb132 Reviews

“All I can say is that this place is the absolute best!

I was diagnosed with breast cancer last year and Alexa has been my go to ever since. She was the only one I could think of to shave my hair after receiving my first Chemo. She made me feel at ease, supported, and safe. She has a genuine authenticity and a beautiful soul. It’s not just about hair with her, she wants to make sure her clients are happy!”

5 Superb40 Reviews

“I have been in the store several times and my experience was nothing but great with friendly and very helpful staff. I am going to return because I had seen things in a catalog that I would like to buy and wanted to see if they carry it in the store. I rather give them my business. Regarding to the one review, mask wearing, at that time it didn't matter if a person was vaccinated or not, mask wearing was a requirement by the CDC to enter any store. The stores needed to comply by the CDC covid-19 policy. Yes, it was an inconvenience. Yes, many of us hated it, but you want or need to go shopping you needed to wear a mask, CDC policy for the state of New York. It wasn't just at this store it was everywhere, stores, banks, a person's job and etc. Any place that was enclosed and had people. It was a very difficult time for us all, very difficult. Therefore the store should not be held responsible for following the CDC policy, they had to. I am eager to go back.”

4.8 Superb45 Reviews

“I had a ring sized smaller. It was done perfectly. It was done sooo quickly. I mentioned that I didn't have a lot to spend, the owner came up with a great solution that was Very Affordable and I am Very pleased. Great work ?- Thank you! - KH”

4.7 Superb58 Reviews

“Excellent teachers in a laid-back atmosphere, that encourages creativity and the development of enhanced skills in both Stainglass and Mosaic work. An absolutely wonderful owner run art experience. One of the few remaining on all of Long Island. I drive out from Long Beach, New York regularly to do my work there and to obtain materials.”

4.9 Superb26 Reviews

“The owner is a sweetheart. I looked all over for special little gifts for my daughter’s bridal shower but couldn’t find what I wanted anywhere. I came into her shop and just fell in love with so many little unique gifts. It’s great to know when I need something special this will be my go to place.”

5 Superb18 Reviews

“I came in really unsure about what to buy and the young woman up front was very helpful. She was patient and knowledgeable. I really appreciated her insight about the various types of gold. I will be coming back and sharing about this store with my friends.”

4.6 Superb32 Reviews

“I recently had the pleasure of working with CJ at Jared to design a perfect, custom engagement ring for my fiancée, and I must say, it was an exceptional experience from start to finish! CJ exceeded my expectations in every way.

From the moment I walked in, CJ was helpful, friendly, kind, and informative, making me feel at ease and educated throughout the entire process. Her expertise and knowledge of the products were impressive and her passion for her work shines through. She consistently stayed in contact with step by step updates throughout the production process. It was lovely to work with someone who genuinely cares about making your experience special.

We couldn't be happier with the final product and it's all thanks to CJ and Jared. Thank you so much!”

4.4 Superb246 Reviews

“Had an amazing experience. Michelle was amazing gave me such valuable information about my rings. I went in with my wedding rings all tarnished and they came out looking brand new. I highly recommend this place.”

4.7 Superb74 Reviews

“After an off-putting experience with an OTHER local jeweler, my fiancé & I came to Lamonica Jewelers to have her engagement ring taken down a size. It was beyond refreshing to deal with all the friendly faces we were greeted with. And the work was excellent. You can tell they really care about their business. They are not just out to get your money; coming here feels like coming to a family-friend. You will not regret choosing Lamonica over any other jeweler.”

4.8 Superb48 Reviews

“The cutest store ever! The owner Joe is the absolute best. He customized embroidered sweatshirts for me for a gift that I needed for that night and when there was a small mistake in the embroidery, he remade them the next day and shipped them all for free. Awesome customer service! Such a great addition to babylon. The tea at their tea cafe is also fantastic.”

4.8 Superb25 Reviews

“Wow! Went here today with my mom to get my necklace fixed and not only did the jewler immediately know how to solve my problem but he also fixed it on the house! Such an amazing experience. I will be back in the future for any of my jewlery needs!”

4.8 Superb32 Reviews

“I came into this zales outlet location with the intend to just look around. Christin approached me within seconds and welcomed me in. Automatically my expectations were exceeded with the small time I was with her, amazing service ! I will definitely be taking the long drive to this location for any and all future jewelry purchases, She is truly the best !”

4.4 Superb75 Reviews

“John is the man! Not only an absolute expert in jewelry and has great customer service but truly a one of a kind jeweler that you won’t find anywhere else. Highly recommend for all and any issues you may have or if you are just looking to purchase a quality product he knows everything there is know!”

4.5 Superb83 Reviews