Jewelry Stores in Bay Shore, NY

8 locations found near Bay Shore
View Map

“Such a beautiful store! So many unique things, great for finding gifts. And the Christmas store! You have a fantastic buyer who has elegant taste. Such fun doing my Christmas shopping!”

4.8 Superb35 Reviews

“Exceptional Service from Andrea and Sal at Kay Jewelers!We recently had the pleasure of shopping at Kay Jewelers and were delighted by the outstanding service provided by Andrea and Sal! Their knowledge, professionalism, and genuine enthusiasm for helping me and my fiancé find the perfect engagement ring made our experience truly memorable.Thank you once again for the wonderful experience.Alex and Tetiana”

4.7 Superb25 Reviews

“Super helpful staff, with a great attitude.Gave out good advice, asking questions I had not thought of.Prices seem too high on gold items, but silver prices seemed fair.”

4.6 Superb12 Reviews

“had a very good experience at this claire’s. a little dirty but nothing is ever not dirty. had a very pleasant and enjoyable experience getting helped by rachel. will shop again”

4 Good7 Reviews

“It seems like just yesterday, when I first came here to propose to my wife, we bought both an engagement and wedding band here. The size of the stone was like half a carat, but ten years later, we returned my wife needed an upgrade, and I thought she deserved it, so we repaired Exchange. Ambica took great care of us. She was very courteous and professional in showing us the different rings and sizes of the diamonds. We saw different types of jewelry. They sell wedding bands, rings, bracelets, earrings, and chains, among other things. We primarily focused on wedding rings and bands. My wife fell in love with a two and one fifth carat diamond ?. This ring was glittering so hard ? I almost lost sight staring at it, and it was love in the air for my wife. She was more infatuated and obsessed with Love Verawang's engagement and anniversary band. I had to get them even though it went way over budget. After ten years of marriage, it is well worth the investment.”

3.9 Good18 Reviews

“These two men are wonderful. They're wonderful, professional, honest, and knowledgeable. They are kind and always willing to do great work on my jewelry and watches.”

3.6 Good7 Reviews

“I have used Empire several times to obtain small loans of a few $100 and then paid to get my jewelry back...no problem. They give me a realistic amount for what I bring to them and are always straightforward.”

3.6 Good27 Reviews

“Great experience and staff. After horrible service at another location I decided to try bay shore. They help me resolve all my concerns. they didn’t have an item and when I told them I didn’t want to go to another store they said no problem we can order it here for you and let you know when it’s in. They did say it could take a bit if the item was sold out, but I’d rather wait than return to smith haven. I’ll gladly wait a few weeks. I left feeling great as they were so kind. They even offered and cleaned my jewelry for free without me asking! I will be back!”

2.2 Poor10 Reviews