Toy Stores near South Orange, NJ

30 locations found near South Orange
View Map

“I found this toy store totally by chance, and the customer service is great! They have a great selection of toys. I was able to order over the phone, they wrapped it for a birthday gift, and did curbside delivery! the staff were so helpful and made the process very easy.”

4.2 Good11 Reviews

“Took my son here for the first time, he has been asking me since he saw their table at NA day event. He’s very into Pokémon cards right now. As we were browsing one of the gentlemen gave him a Halloween pack right away. We bought 3 packs and had a good conversation. As we were about to leave the 2 guys gave my son a whole stack of holographic cards for free. There ended up being a holographic gyrados in that stack of cards and my son has been hoping for that card in every pack he opens, it made his day. Great customer service and highly recommend. Great people. Thank you again!”

4.8 Superb87 Reviews

“First time visiting this Comicbook store and instantly felt like they knew me for years . The owner Jose was very very welcoming and very knowledgeable! I stated it was my first time really purchasing comic books , he instantly took his time to educate me in the kindest manner . 20/10 for this awesome place !Friendly staff , awesome prices , great location and awesome an awesome collection !”

4.7 Superb83 Reviews

“i found this place a few years ago while i was in the area on vacation. the owner took care of me. this place has the best prices around and they have almost everything you need in stock. i was there again this year an between me an my friends we bout another 6 cars from them. thank you for your help tech toys”

4.6 Superb73 Reviews

“Who knew you could make such AMAZING creations out of LEGO, back in the day LEGO was just DUPLO, It's obvious that Lego is not just for kids anymore! Visiting the Lego store today was such a wonderful experience, from the Lego Storm Trooper which greeted us at the door, to the Bouquets of Flowers further in.”

4.6 Superb72 Reviews

“My 14 year old daughter is recently obsessed with Jelly cat. She wanted to visit a store that carried them and we were not disappointed. Her face lit up like a little kid again as soon as we walked in. They had a great selection of not just Jelly Cat items but other toys as well. We spent well over an hour there just looking around.”

4.6 Superb59 Reviews

“This is a great shop with lots of things for kids. The employees are always very nice and the store is pet-friendly. I usually walk my dogs here and purchase stuffed animals. The prices are what you'd expect for a small business in a middle-upper class neighborhood. While I like this store and supporting it, it's definitely not for those who are trying to save money. I've found that most of their Squishmallows are from discount stores such as Costco and 5below, then sold for double the price. I don't know what the mark up is for other brands they carry. The prices have also gone up a lot. Summer 2021 I bought a 16-inch Squishmallow for $25, and now they sell them for $38. Nonetheless, I will continue to support the buissness fervently.”

4.9 Superb22 Reviews

“Very personalized therapy fromoutstanding therapist. Location is great, facility is clean and open with nocrowding, efficient, pleasant receptionistA plus facility”

5 Superb17 Reviews

“It's really nice having a local toy/hobby shop around. They have a great selection of new and used toys and trains. Also a great place for a party once COVID is over. Please support businesses like this!”

4.8 Superb23 Reviews

“Amazing store. Very clean. Well stocked. Amazing customer service from Store Manager Tasha and her wonderful staff. From the time my family and I walked in and we're greeted with a huge smile, to the time we checked out, and was greeted as we left out the store. So glad to have 5 below at Essex Green Mall.”

4.7 Superb27 Reviews

“Great shop to visit if you are into Funko Pops. As soon as you enter, you are surrounded by pops everywhere. Most shops just carry a million commons but Wize Guys carry a huge variety of pops from old to new. Definitely worth a visit!”

4.5 Superb40 Reviews

“Great space for gaming with dedicated parking. Nearby food options within walking distance are good too. Customer service here is top quality. Chairs are comfortable.”

4.6 Superb25 Reviews

“Convenient, helpful and very pleasant staff. Doesn't have everything that Staples does BUT you'll always find what you need. So thankful that this small business thrives and is supported by our community.”

4.7 Superb18 Reviews

“The Paper Store very nice unique items for the holidays or any occasion. I bought a few Christmas gifts, the prices are reasonable and the quality is good. Also, the customer service was great and a speedy checkout.”

4.3 Superb71 Reviews

“Great selection and a friendly staff. Some of the sections, like fantasy especially, could stand to be a little bigger, lots of big names in the genre missing, but a decent selection. Quick check out time too.”

4.3 Superb49 Reviews

“The store was fully stocked with fabulous Christmas stuff. They just need more cashiers. The line was very long with only 2 cashiers and the self check out closed.”

4.6 Superb14 Reviews

“Absolutely amazing experience and 100% recommend! Customer service is absolutely amazing and I’m so appreciative for a company like this in 2023. Thank you all so much! I will definitely be purchasing again <3”

5 Superb7 Reviews

“One of the last Disney stores still open! Definitely worth the trip. Had some good deals on some items and some new items as well. A must go if you are a Disney fan and in the area!”

4.3 Superb35 Reviews

“I had the best experience at This Five below. Everyone was super polite and helpful, especially Dante. Dante really gave me the help I needed. He was really easy on the eyes too so that helped?”

4.3 Superb34 Reviews

“This was my first purchase with Camp Stuff 4 Less - it was an amazing experience! I ordered two personalized items and they arrived how I ordered them. However, when they arrived I realized that I didn’t choose the correct color vinyl for a folding chair. Lori was beyond generous and offered for me to send the chair back and they would fix it! Again - this wasn’t their mistake, it was my mistake as I choose the wrong color. Excellent communication and customer service! I’m so appreciative!”

4.5 Superb13 Reviews

“Honestly we were just looking. We did not buy anything here. They have a really great selection of board games, puzzles and calendars! They have some great collectibles also. If you are looking for a gift for that weird person who you never know what to get, as long as you know 1 thing about them, you can easily find something here. From board games based on any semi popular show to general toys of all ages, they have it all. Anything that can be made into a game can be found here lol! It is definitely a nice little location, I wanted like 3 of their monopoly sets, but sadly they would just collect dust! If you want a specific one, they have it! Amazing selection of all kinds of games. One day when I have a man cave I will come back and probably buy half the store lol! They also have a ton of card games!!! From Pokémon to CAH, they have it, they even have weird sets! All in all a very nice little location. They are a chain! Staff is very friendly, if you dont see something, just ask, they might be able to find it or order it for you. Store is also very very clean! Staff really pays attention to make sure about that.”

4.4 Superb17 Reviews

“This is a dream come true for all those like me who love animé.I could not stop falling in love with all figures. They have Japanese and Chinese ones. The quality is impressive. Costumer service is great and prices are reasonable.”

4.3 Superb21 Reviews

“Beautiful clothing for babies! Went to buy stuff for my newborn and loved the collection of clothing. Very unique and high quality. Will definitely go back for baby gifts for others again”

4.8 Superb5 Reviews

“We had so much fun making our stuffed animals today. Sarah was so patient and kind with our very indecisive crew. She took the time to explain what she was going to do next and made sure all purchases were parent approved (much appreciated!) She was on alone and was very efficient when a line stared to form. We didn’t feel rushed at all and no one waited for a long time. We had a really great experience from start to finish. Someone give Sarah a raise! She was absolutely lovely, excellent customer service! Thank you so much Sarah for the special experience and for telling us about the Build A Bear show on Netflix! We’re already obsessed!”

4.2 Good22 Reviews

“This is a unique train store I ever seen! This place is amazing, Ed is a friendly guy and has a lot of antique trains and plenty of items that will suit for model train layouts.”

5 Superb3 Reviews

“This bookstore is large and pleasant, it has a large number of titles for children, it has a coffee shop where you can spend a pleasant time and many windows, which allow you to enjoy natural light. The only thing that would improve is to add children's books in Spanish, my son is 6 years old and loves to read in English and Spanish and is learning to speak French but it is difficult to find children's books in these languages.”

4.1 Good67 Reviews

“My favorite toy store ever! The perfect place for any child or even adults who are into whimsical little creations. A friendly vibe as soon as you walk in and when you leave. The store smells great, clean, and has a wide range of toys newborn to age 99. I will definitely be back. Thank you for the pleasant experience.”

4.2 Good12 Reviews

“This store has been around for 25 years, so there must be something to it. There is. The owner, Linda is incredible! She's been a family friend my entire life. She's accommodating and if you give her your budget, she has this uncanny ability to pick a gift out. I've bought numerous gifts from this place and will continue to do so in the future.”

4.5 Superb4 Reviews

“I went into the GameStop in Lyndhurst to buy the New Xbox generation and Craig who was working couldn’t have helped me more. A great employee with an even better attitude. I will ensure that I come back to the GameStop in Lyndhurst to do business because of employees like that. He couldn’t have been more respectful and cooperative.”

4.1 Good24 Reviews