Hardware Stores near New Haven, IN

20 locations found near New Haven
View Map

“Absolutely wonderful selection! Varied.. they have clothes, tools, everything a hardware store should have, and more! This place even has a very elaborate, home wine/beer making section dedicated to the original owner. It has EVERYTHING a home brewer would ever need!! And they know what all of it is for!! The staff are downright sweet, friendly, and helpful.”

4.7 Superb12 Reviews

“Great place very !.!.!. knowledgeable very friendly. Don't let the size of the office / shop building fool you that place is pack packed .with good deals, they service and sell stihl .I bought a chainsaw from them and I am extremely happy with it...”

4.9 Superb18 Reviews

“Everyone was very friendly and answered all my questions I asked. They were willing to take time with me to get the right materials I needed. If anyone is looking for paint guns, car paint, detailing products and more I would go to this location. Very good customer service and I’d be glad to go back sooner or later.”

4.6 Superb48 Reviews

“You overcharged i was going to you install stereo but i did it myself you still charged me laber i will call you tomorrow to get my 300.00 back Thank you Jerry Teague”

4.7 Superb27 Reviews

“It had been awhile since I was there. They have rearranged the store but it looks good. No more flyers sent out in mailings, its all done online now. Prices do not seem to be affected, so you still get a good deal.”

4.5 Superb37 Reviews

“Shop at Connolly's often for many fixer upper needs, whether it's paint, cheesecloth, birdseed, furnace filters, nails, rental equipment, etc. Very friendly, helpful, knowledgeable salesperson. Great place to shop.”

5 Superb5 Reviews

“It was nice. Kind of small. You could tell that they catered to the Amish community. I still found items to buy that I wouldn't have found at other hardware stores.”

4.5 Superb8 Reviews

“I am a member of Do it Best Corp Toastmasters. This is a wonderful place to learn and grow both personally and professionally. We are a friendly and helpful bunch of people who welcome everyone to attend. Come check it out.”

4.3 Superb36 Reviews

“From the moment I entered this business, I was greeted by such kind, helpful and friendly staff!! I had such a great experience being able to sit down with Tammy, and I look forward to being able to do it again real soon!!”

4.8 Superb3 Reviews

“Amazing staff! Ask any question and they know exactly which aisle! I was often guided to the location when I wasn't totally sure of the item I needed. They were incredibly helpful with great suggestions! The store is so well set up and fully stocked and the prices are great!”

4.3 Superb17 Reviews

“I really appreciate the help they give and am more than thrilled with the products they have that I'm unable to find elsewhere! BUT they could definitely fix their driveway as the curb is EXTREMELY steep for a motorcycle to drive up it and smacked my frame given I was SUPER slow and even at an angle so..... ?”

4.2 Good27 Reviews

“I want to say thank you to Steve and Greg for their great customer service this morning. I had to get a key cut and had a rough morning and they were so friendly, reassuring, and helpful.”

4.1 Good9 Reviews

“Had the greatest experience with Alex! He’s a great guy who is always willing to help and answer all of my many questions! He’s been my go-to guy after a couple of bad experiences with Mark. Alex definitely takes care of his customers with patience and grace (hard to find nowadays). 5 stars are only for Alex!”

4.1 Good13 Reviews

“An eclectic crowd to say the least.It is a good Menards store.They keep it up well.Some of the workers aren't the best when it comes to customer service.For the most part it is just fine.Quite a selection of everything.”

4.1 Good37 Reviews

“As overwhelmed as I was trying to locate a KA-90 anode rod today and finding out this store is the only place to purchase one in the entire city... once I finally found my answers, I was very pleased with how helpful the associates were. They were incredibly busy with business and residential orders this Friday afternoon, but still were lighthearted, patient, and more than willing to answer any questions I had to ask. I would recommend checking them out if you're in the market for something. I felt as comfortable as I could be.”

3.7 Good24 Reviews

“Gabriel does an amazing job! I had him the past couple visits at lowes. He took time to make sure we got the correct items we needed and asked important questions about our projects. If you have Gabe help you, you will be very satisfied!”

3.7 Good35 Reviews

“Aside from the fact it was my first visit and though disappointing to find that they do not have Weaver Popcorn (a brand of popcorn from my hometown of Van Buren and getting that item at the Southtown location), yet an okay location.”

3.5 Good41 Reviews

“I never know what I may find in The ReStore. Things go through there so fast, if you want it, Do Not Leave it. You may never see it again. I got a hand made ballot box with a hasp on it for $10 today. #JackpotFind”

2.6 Average9 Reviews