My go-to place to sell and buy. Maybe not the broadest selection, but they are knowledgeable and treat the customer very well. Good place to buy collection supplies.
November 2023
Today we bought multiple coins from this place and the service was great, the coins reasonably priced. Spencer was really cool to work with.
August 2023
Very knowledgeable and fair shop. They know what they're doing. Straight forward. Easier to come in than call. The person who answer the phone is a little peculiar
Currently our public hours are Friday 10-6 and Saturday 9-3. Lost Dutchman Rare Coins has been the premier full service coin shop in Indianapolis since 1983. We specialize in buying and selling collectible coins, paper money, and bullion. As a family run local business we value our customers.
