Thrift Stores in Fishers, IN

“I had a wonderful experience shopping here! The sales person Kim was amazing! She puts a lot of care and love into her job! She helped me find the items I needed. I was in awe of how much they had! Panty hose, mop heads, hula hoops, etc! The options are endless. Need yarn? Go there! I could explore for hours. It’s well organized and the staff is great! Highly recommend!”

“I had a good thrifting experience here as it was my first time at this location. I love the book section & they had some nice books. Overall the store was clean & it didn't smell bad so that's a plus! Friendly cashier's & decent prices. I will definitely return to this location when I'm in the area!”

“The staff is very kind! We brought our 3 year old daughter in earlier this week. The staff went out of their way to greet her and Madisyn even handed her two quarters from her own pocket to use in the candy vendors at the front of the store. What a great staff!”

“My granddaughter, and I stopped in to get a few books the other day. After leaving the store, my granddaughter could not find her doggy purse and thought she left it behind there. We turned around the car and went back to look for it. The wonderful staff and store manager all got involved to help. They all stopped what they were doing to help the little girl find her purse. The kind manager even looked at the surveillance footage on the camera. The camera showed that she walked out of the store with a purse over her shoulder. Needless to say, she left it somewhere else. That was above and beyond customer service. We are very grateful and thankful for everyone’s help and kindness. Thank you to everyone and the staff.”

“Hello! I’ve been a very frequent flyer of this Plato’s Closet in Fishers since I moved to Indiana in 2015. All my friends will tell you that Plato’s Closet is my favorite store. It’s true! If you ask me on ANY day where I got my top, my answer will be “Plato’s Closet” 90% of the time. This may sound strange but it’s where I always go after a hard day; it’s like an oasis for me. Sometimes retail therapy is the best therapy & their clothes are better for my wallet & of remarkable quality. They’re obviously very careful to purchase items that are in mint condition & on trend. It’s also smaller inside & less intimidating than the mall or a large department store, which I appreciate as an introvert. They have a little bit of everything in stock too! I buy all my work attire here (quarter zips & polos), clothes for nicer events (bridal showers, family gatherings, etc), and for a good ol’ fashioned Girls Night Out! I highly recommend!”