Silver City Sarasota is a wonderful store with a great selection of beautiful and unique jewelry. It carries many unique and custom pieces, including the special Siesta Key Watercolor Gemstone jewelry, which serves as a uniquely Siesta Key reminder of the beautiful beach. The jewelry is eye-catching and available at various price points. The staff is outstanding, professional, kind, welcoming, fun, and inviting. They do not rush customers and take great care, even taking jewelry outside for a better view or carefully wrapping purchases. They provide wonderful service, including cleaning jewelry to look like new and offering fast, super cheap fixes for repairs like resizing rings or fixing clasps, sometimes with no charge. The experience is always wonderful and highly recommended.
Great place to shop. Beautiful and unique pieces. Excellent customer service.
May 2026
I have trusted Silver city in Sarasota Siesta key for many years with my jewelry they are kind and honest and truly care about their customers and their prices are reasonable their integrity give me peace of mind You . I highly recommend silver city. They are the best. I recommend this place wholeheartedly
May 2026
Tris and Monica helped me find the perfect gift for my sister in law, a beautiful, Sterling silver gem stone pendant for her too remember Siesta Key. The store is impressive with a large variety of jewelry pieces and the friendly, knowledgeable staff is a bonus.
