Jewelry Stores in Sarasota, FL

30 locations found near Sarasota
View Map

“George is the BEST for jewelry repair and re-sizing. Superb skilled workmanship! As a local Sarasota resident for many decades I wouldn’t go anyplace else! Silver City is a beautiful store with excellent customer service from long-time employees. Definitely the place to go for beautiful quality Siesta Key jewelry keepsake pieces.”

5 Superb135 Reviews

“This is an excellent pawn shop! The owners are so nice and extremely trustworthy!. In such a competitive market, they really shine. They offer the best prices around. They also have great items for sale. Look no further.”

5 Superb58 Reviews

“I'm newer to the area and needed to get some jewelry appraised for insurance purposes. I had a wonderful experience with Thayer Jewelers. They were welcoming, thoughtful about the process, and very efficient in getting the appraisals back to me. I also enjoyed browsing the showroom. They have beautiful jewelry and a large assortment. Highly recommend.”

5 Superb45 Reviews

“You have got to check out this FUN little gift shop tucked in between some delicious restaurants. We will definitely be going back every time we're in the area. I only wish I could have bought a lot more than I did.”

5 Superb44 Reviews

“My wife and I have been married for 31 glorious years and she has always wanted an eternity diamond ring. We have had quite a remarkable journey together that I felt she was way overdue for a gift she longed for. She is my strength and rock and deserves having this pleasure. McCarver & Moser was the only jeweler we trust and we have been thoroughly impressed with not only the product but the impeccable service with all their staff, especially Opal their mascot. Thank you ever so much for making our life that much more beautiful!! Best, Ken”

5 Superb37 Reviews

“A big shout out to Evan at Mayors, UTC Mall location! I have been on a Rolex wait list at Mayors for about 3 months. Every 3 weeks or so I would stop by, and reaffirm my interest in a particular Rolex with Evan. Update to present, by sheer luck I was able to purchase the watch I had been searching for from an authorized dealer on the other coast of Florida. Getting home with my new watch, I felt the bracelet was not sized correctly. I took it into Mayors, and Evan very graciously worked with me to get the bracelet correct. He took it back a three times to do adjustments that he recognized would make it perfect. I really appreciate Evan’s calm and professional approach in my every interaction with him. If you are looking for a quality experience in making a watch purchase, please see Evan at Mayors!”

4.9 Superb64 Reviews

“Stayed the night in Sarasota on my way to St. Pete a couple weeks ago with my best friend and walked past this place so many times while they were closed, waited around for them to open, I am SO GLAD we did. I can’t remember her name, but she had dirty blonde hair was the sweetest women ever. The whole vibe of this shop is unlike any other. High quality beautiful pieces. We both ended up getting moldavite necklaces. I’d come back to Sarasota from WI just to come here ❤️”

5 Superb32 Reviews

“Melinda and Kelly took good care of me today. Very wonderful ladies with great customer service skill and respectful. They were fast and helped with all my needs. Thanks ladies I’ll be coming back.I recommend this place 5star”

4.9 Superb53 Reviews

“Kirk made me feel very comfortable and was extremely fair. He has been in Sarasota for a very long time and has a very extensive clientele that have also been in the area a long time.It was my first time there but he made me a lifetime customer today.”

4.9 Superb46 Reviews

“We bought our lamp and rug from Max last year and fell in love with it. Not only was Max so incredibly kind and loving, but we make sure to stop by every year we are in town to say hello and see what treasures he has to offer. This year we bought 4 beautiful plates to hang in our kitchen! Can't wait to see the final look. Make sure to stop by when you are looking at all the shops in St. Armands Circle, by far the best in our opinion.”

5 Superb27 Reviews

“Milan was super friendly and has the experience I was looking for to resize my fiancés engagement ring. He even got it done earlier than promised which is why I came here after reading other reviews! We will be back for some custom made jewelry!”

5 Superb27 Reviews

“Well she said YES! Thank you Rob for making my dreams come true. Rob designed and created my engagement ring and it was beautiful. Hands down the best experience I have had. Again, thank you.”

4.9 Superb40 Reviews

“I live in San Diego and visit a friend in Sarasota. This was my fourth trip and forth visit to Gold Coast Pawn. I love this place, they have so many fabulous jewelry pieces I can hardly choose which to bring home. Rick and Krissi are the best! No pressure, easy to work, helpful and extremely enjoyable to chat with!! I have found a treasure each time I’ve visited. Highly recommend great merchandise and great people!!”

5 Superb24 Reviews

“My first product I got here was a stainless steal necklace and it works as a charm it works for wherever I go from gym to beach to anywhere. Then recently I got another necklace but real silver, and I got it for a great deal and plan on getter more when I see something that gets my attention”

5 Superb24 Reviews

“L O V E! A must visit whether you’re local or visiting. The cutest store that carries the best and most flattering brands and styles from athletic wear to Summer dresses. Kendall, the owner is an absolute doll face and a true Sarasotian. Support this cute local biz! To our surprise also had permanent jewelry! So fun!”

5 Superb23 Reviews

“Absolutely love this boutique! I recently bought a necklace here and I love it! The clothes are very nice and perfect for the Florida weather! The owner is very kind and really cares about the customer experience!”

5 Superb20 Reviews

“The Bazaar on Apricot & Lime is an indoor market, with over 40 local creators and curators. The 5,000 square foot space has an enormous variety of gifts that has something for everyones taste. From art, collectibles, clothing, jewelry, one-of-a-kind items, plants, home decor, gifts, and a food truck outside.We went to the bazaar that date at night they were having a talent show. The place was packed. This place is a very festive and joyful place. They have sodas, water and alcohol drinks for sale. There is also a food truck called "Hamlets Eatery" that sells fresh, very tasty mouthwatering dishes with a nice variety of plates to choose from at a reasonable price. The talent show was full of local talent from dual jugglers and singers and young dancers who performed a wonderful dance from their culture wearing beautiful outfits to a familiar local woman doing comedy who played the washboard while singing and telling funny stories. We all had a fun time! I would definitely recommend this place if you're looking for a place to go and relax and have a good time with friends. The Bazaar on Apricot and Lime definitely is a place to be, filled with laughter and friendly service, good food and plenty of smiles.”

4.8 Superb55 Reviews

“What a charming little place to get creative or throw a party! We took a pottery class and loved every minute of it- our instructor was super cool and even more patient. The boutique itself has a lot of cute items made by local artists and is fun to dig around in.”

5 Superb19 Reviews

“This was the Best experience ever! Michelle helped us and she was amazing! She was so very helpful and never pushy. She made us feel like our happiness and experience were important to her. She took a possibly overwhelming situation and made it very comfortable. So take our advice and ask for her if you go! We will always be grateful for her.”

4.8 Superb51 Reviews

“Giovanna & Misch are both amazing together! My husband and I were very happy with the craftsmanship of the work done here and the communication was very good! We got a custom band made for a ring from the 1930s and it came out stunning! Also sizing and making sure all the diamonds and sapphires stay in place because the ring is so old! We are very pleased and will return when we need anything else.. we had the ring shipped from Florida to NJ without any issue.. if you are looking for excellent craftsmanship and unique custom pieces or modern, whatever you need, it’s right here and they are ? so you can feel completely confident.. Oh and they went above & beyond to get my ring back to me in a very good time frame around their busiest season as I was getting married.. They exceeded the typical timeframe ?”

4.9 Superb25 Reviews

“Just Because isn’t only an amazing store with incredibly unique and fun inventory, but I always feel so welcome by the helpful, kind and caring sales associates. Thank you, Roberta for making my shopping experience a pure delight!”

4.8 Superb37 Reviews

“I ❤️❤️❤️ this boutique. I stumbled upon in when driving home one day. The name is Maco Made in Colombia. It’s in Gulf Gate (Sarasota). The owner is a treasure. The store is bright and colorful. My eyes kept jumping from one beautiful thing to the next. There is handmade jewelry, handmade hats, dolls, purses, bowls, the list goes on. I absolutely recommend a visit to the store.As an extra bonus, they do events like Salsa dancing, wine and cheese, empanadas tasting, just to make a few. I will definitely go back for my holiday shopping!”

5 Superb15 Reviews

“(Translated by Google) I loved it…the super customer service and the best prices you can find in jewelry are there…I recommend it 100%(Original)Me encanto…la atención al cliente super y los mejores precios que puedas encontrar en joyas están ahí..lo recomiendo 100%”

4.9 Superb19 Reviews

“A beautiful gallery with beautiful jewelry and beautiful people. Everyone should go and see for themselves. But be aware it is hard to go in without buying something.”

4.8 Superb30 Reviews

“This place is incredible. I am a very picky New Englander and like a very specific type of chunky sterling silver jewelry (without compromising on quality). Let me tell you that Bowman Originals does not disappoint. I am blown away by the craftsmanship, and the owners (Ned and Rowan) are the loveliest duo - you can tell they pour their heart into their jewelry/art. Very, VERY pleased.Edit: I have now purchased three pieces from Bowman Originals, working with Ned over the last few months to customize at least 2/3 of them. I can honestly say I have never worked with an artist (a jeweler, specifically) that has gone to such great lengths to ensure I am satisfied and get exactly what I want - no matter how picky. I will definitely be working with the Bowman team in the future!!”

5 Superb13 Reviews

“This is one of the friendliest and most competent jewelry and watch repair stores. They did a very professional repair on my favorite watch and had it ready when it was promised. Will definitely use them in the future.”

5 Superb12 Reviews

“Great place for bullion and coins. And good to have a trustworthy and local brick-and-mortar store for high-value items in Sarasota. I met Glenn and Mike at their Gold, Coin, and Jewelry store today. Very approachable, super nice guys, knowledgeable, and very fair and transparent regarding pricing. Definitely going back there for more coins.”

4.8 Superb21 Reviews

“Amazing store and great store manager. Came in this evening and they had an artist Karren Garces presenting her art, live music and sip and shop. Bought some irresistable home decor and candles. Thank you for being such a great host, I always have fun in your store!!”

5 Superb10 Reviews

“Had the best time visiting and viewing these exquisite hand made /original design pieces of art jewelry. Everyone was kind and informed about the pieces. Absolutely made my vacay. Thank you thank you. Definitely will return!”

5 Superb10 Reviews

“I can’t say enough about my wonderful experience with Golden Imagine!! From the minute I walked in the door I felt comfortable and my pieces were done perfectly! What a great team! Thank you!!”

4.9 Superb13 Reviews

You May Also Like