Jewelry Stores near Whitefish Bay, WI

28 locations found near Whitefish Bay

“Love this store, has a great selection of items and so fun to browse when in Whitefish Bay. Store owner is so nice and she hand makes the softest baby items. My daughter loves her little blanket I bought from here.”

4.2 Good60 Reviews

“I had the most wonderful day experience. Angelo is a gem! I will only be purchasing from here going forward. Thank you so much for helping me pick out the most amazing birthday gift for my special guy!”

5 Superb172 Reviews

“I worked with Tuezdae and she was a great sales person spoke to me soon as entered and told me have a great night as I left …. Best customer service I’ve had in a long time”

4.8 Superb196 Reviews

“Had an amazing experience at Powers! We went to several jewelers looking for an engagement ring, and by far had the best experience here. Gregg took excellent care of us and was patient and kind throughout the whole process. Will definitely be back in the future.”

4.9 Superb148 Reviews

“My partner and I brought our engagement ring here to be resized. He did not buy the ring here but from the moment we walked in, we were treated with utmost kindness and respect by Ryan and the team. We were offered some waters, a place to sit, we were encouraged to talk about our ring and our wedding plans. Ryan was very thorough in making sure that because my ring band is unique in shape/pattern, resizing it wouldn't cause a problem. Together with their jewelsmith, they looked very carefully and assured me that they can resize the ring correctly and to my preferred tightness level. They quoted us a week and we got a notice a few days later that it would be ready for pickup the following Monday. We were greeted and recognized by Ryan as soon as we walked in to pick it up and when I inspected the ring, it was excellent! I had to tell them, I was so nervous about it but it turned out great. I did not catch the name of their jewelsmith but I got to say thank-you to her personally as she came out to let us know she enjoyed working on the ring. We appreciate so much the effort it took to mimic the band style, size down to a perfect O shape and have everything done on time. We appreciate the friendliness and respect we were treated with. I recommend this location to anyone considering a jewel purchase for any special occasion. Thanks again from Elsa&Matt.”

4.9 Superb119 Reviews

“Took my idea for a pendant, as a gift for my wife, to celebrate our 50th Wedding Anniversary and asked if they could come up with a design. The design was more than a WOW! It has details on it that are unbelievably beautiful. My wife was amazed and happy at what was created. It definitely is a "one of a kind" creation.

Barnes Goldmiths has never disappointed us.”

4.9 Superb63 Reviews

“With the price of gold as high as it is, I brought some old jewelry here to sell. The gentleman is as honest and fair and genuinely pleasant as all the other reviewers say. This was a great experience. Some jewelry had a little bit of sentimental value (although the $ value outweighed that). This gentleman is friendly and kind. He explained everything about what I had, what it is worth retail, what he will do with it, etc. I know he gave me the highest price of any other dealer in the Racine-Milwaukee area. It was nearly an hour drive and totally worth it. You can't do better than doing business here.”

4.8 Superb71 Reviews

“truly stunning pieces of jewelry and an incredible selection. the only downside is i want to buy up the whole store! i would highly recommend to anyone looking to buy a timeless gift for a loved one or themselves. it’s also a fantastic place to work and learn”

4.9 Superb73 Reviews

“David is so knowledge and helpful throughout the entire process. He designed my engagement/wedding band and was so thoughtful on every detail. He communicated well throughout the whole process and was respectful of our budget. Would highly recommend.”

5 Superb31 Reviews

“There is a fair amount of anxiety and stress that comes when opting to redesign a beautiful family heirloom with 100 or so years of history. Will it mean as much? How do we honor the original while making it more us? Who can we trust to do this work?

For us, the answer was Amy. One conversation with her about what our hope and vision was, and she shared an absolutely gorgeous (and perfect) design that capture exactly what we had been hoping to achieve.

We could not be more excited about the end result, and would 10/10 recommend Amy and A Trio to anyone.

-Kristin & John”

4.9 Superb82 Reviews

“I had an amazing experience! There are so many beautiful and amazing options for clothing. The customer service was the best! I would definitely recommend this place for anyone who’s looking for cultural clothes!”

4.9 Superb17 Reviews

“I want to give a glowing review of the ladies at Cival. Everyone is so kind and helpful. I love this store! I found great gifts, and I couldn't leave without a few treats for myself. I found a lovely men's ring for a friend's bday, and the pop-up shop for Valentine's Day actually helped me tackle friend's bday gifts. I adore the range of styles and sizes, and the attention from staff is pleasant and warm. Add Cival to your list of Milwaukee shopping spots!”

4.8 Superb45 Reviews

“Kloiber Jewelers is a downtown jewelry store with a small town feel. A number of years ago, they helped me design a stunning wedding ring. Its one of a kind design truly celebrates the love the bride and groom feel for one another.

This year, Karin went out of her way to track down a perfect piece for my daughter. She called all sorts of people to find the right thing. Kloiber Jewelers is an asset to our community.”

5 Superb68 Reviews

“I love this place! My husband got my wedding/engagement rings resized here. The quality of work, speed of service, customer service and price were all outstanding. I've never been to a jewelry business that was so warm and thorough.”

4.8 Superb58 Reviews

“Great place to stop for great deals and awesome quality. I like stopping here to purchase gifts every time we are in Milwaukee. I recommend stopping by to see what treasures you'll pick up”

4.6 Superb41 Reviews

“Best jewelry in town. Great prices and great service. On site jewler. Amazing selection. Anything you need they have. They have been in business for a long time for a reason!”

4.7 Superb87 Reviews

“Brought my wife’s wedding ring in for some major repairs and when they were done, it looked better than when I first bought it 13 years ago. Another reputable jeweler had told me it was unfixable. Steve was wonderful to work with. He was thorough and transparent without ever being pushy. Highly recommend them!”

5 Superb36 Reviews

“No need to even try and haggle. He knows his stuff, and immediately gives about the fairest offer possible. Very honest as well, and will make offers on gems too instead of only giving the value of the gold minus whatever stone.”

4.7 Superb19 Reviews

“I literally am obsessed with this store. Right when you walk in, it’s an experience. It smells amazing in there and makes me want to buy all the candles. They have an amazing selection of plants, gifts, jewelry & incense. If I ever need a gift for someone I go here! The staff & owner are so kind!”

4.8 Superb72 Reviews

“good variety of jewelry, rings, necklaces, earrings, and pendants. i get my jewelry from here all the time. my family and i love the selection of jewelry they have to offer. definitely recommend coming here!!!”

4.8 Superb16 Reviews

“the staff is Great ..... did a return was more than happy to help me! the girl they had in the store was knowledgeable and eager to help ! Small town store that's a pleasure to be in! Thank You”

4.6 Superb68 Reviews

“Always a great experience when I come here, its been some years since last going here but ALEX welcomed me nd helped me find exactly what I was looking for!!! When you need the best of the best even when you're on a budget, Choose Reflections nd ask for ALEX!!! YOU WILL NOT BE DISAPPOINTED!!!”

4.4 Superb61 Reviews

“Coleman customer service was amazing, he always has a smile on his face and is very welcome he even put up on the sale, Coleman has me wanting to come back everyday if I could, he's my go to as a sale Rep ?”

4.3 Superb76 Reviews

“I had two sentimental pieces needing repair. A silver “smashed silver ring” and a gold chain needing a larger clasp. Magpie did a wonderful job restoring both..I love the jewelry in the shop And so delighted my daughter bought me a pair of earrings from there for Christmas”

4.8 Superb26 Reviews

“Absolutely the best place with the best customer service. I just left their store 10 mins ago and I decided to give them a review because they absolutely do a great job. People are so nice, kind and friendly there especially the lady ( I don’t know her name I talked to her, but I completely forget to ask her name ). She is amazing. She is very nice, kind and helpful. I’m an Asian I thought due pandemic a lot of people would not like Asians, but she treated me very nice and kind. She explained to me very clearly about the loan and the interest. I would highly recommend this place.”

4.6 Superb25 Reviews

“He's one of the best jeweler in town I like them I like his establishment he should be downtown he's very good and he's very fair he ain't there to stick nobody up”

4.5 Superb18 Reviews

“Diane's Designs had tools and the expertise to engrave my challenge coins. The coins had a very small area that I needed to have engraving done. Other engravers actually sent me to Diane's. I could not be more satisfied with the results. OUTSTANDING ! These were special coins and they could not be in better trusting hands.”

4.4 Superb32 Reviews

“I CAME HERE TWICE BECAUSE THEY'RE FFL DEALERS FIRST TIME WENT SMOOTH 2ND TIME DIDN'T HAD TO COMEBACK BECAUSE THE "CHECK YOUR BACKGROUND" PEOPLE TOOK ALL DAY TO CALL BACK OVERALL COOL PLACE AND THE GUY DECENT TOO.”

4.6 Superb43 Reviews