-
October 2024 by Sara Cartwright
You should take notice of all the bad reviews about the overpricing. But besides that I bought a loot of glass breakables and the cashier just threw them all in a box clinking against each other. When I went to grab the box I noticed there were two drawers full of newspapers behind the counter to wrap stuff in. What laziness!
-
October 2024 by matt schmitt
This place has gone crazy with exuberant prices. I understand that the goal is to raise as much money for their mission, but this is just plain ridiculous. See Attached photo of this USED Mountain Hardwear puffer jacket. They are asking $90.00 for this! This sells for $80-$100 New!!! And to top it off, there was a supposed sale on all their outerwear. LOL. If you call a USED jacket priced at $90.00 a sale.
-
August 2024 by vaughn eiseman
They do not post return policy. Bought item and realized it was damaged. Reported it to them. THEY COULD OF CARED LESS. AND WOULD NOT RETURN , NOR CREDIT IT. So becareful what you buy.
-
April 2024 by DJ Brainscan
Prices here are absolutely ridiculous. The whole point of thrift stores is for you to find "bargains" Everything here is priced to the penny of what it would be worth and in many cases way over what it would be brand new. These are donated items St Vinny's gets for free. Maybe price them a little bit lower folks.
-
February 2024 by Christina Lee
Outrageously priced. Extremely outdated coach bags were over 40.00Some bags were 80. Pajama pants that didn’t come with a matching piece was 12.00 if you would cut your prices in half at least I’m sure you would make a lot more money. This is pure greed. ICame here once and won’t be coming back.
-
February 2024 by Joe
I prefer St. Vinny’s over other thrift stores, mainly because of their variety. The service is typically more consistent throughout locations vs. other resellers. Their drop/off service is very quick and easy!
-
February 2024 by Carol Larsen
Great array of 2nd hand everything
-
January 2024 by Harmony Lynn
Prices here are astronomical. I've picked up a few pieces I considered purchasing new, only to see they were actually marked higher than they were new. I love Vinny's normally, their food pantry saved my life, but this store needs new management. They have forgotten why they are there, they have really given in to greed.
-
January 2024 by Rachel K
Do t go here if you’re looking to thrift value under $30. Super disappointed to see used clothing resold for that price at a thrift store.
-
December 2023 by Matt Martin
I work from home and use this store to take breaks, so I’m there often. What a wonderful establishment. I buy about a baker’s dozen books per week, and new options are are added consistently.The employees are incredible. They are always friendly, even when some bitter elderly woman is screaming about the prices of random glassware. You don’t need another vase, you old shrew.This store is always clean and well-organized. I can never find jeans, but this is an issue at many Madison thrift stores. Another reason might be that I’m tall and muscular, so the jeans I’m searching for aren’t frequently donated. What was I talking about?
-
November 2023 by Rebecca Bray
Prices are outrageous. A pair of jeans $20. A pair of nylon tennis shoes $26. Apparently they have an Outdoor Chic line now...MANY items priced above what you would pay if bought brand new. This is not thrift, this is theft.
-
November 2023 by j.thomas
Worst prices of any thrift store in the entire Madison metro area. Even worse than the Middleton goodwill. They had pants on the rack for 40 dollars. Disgusting levels of greed.
-
November 2023 by Kyong Burgher
Great food and service
-
November 2023 by Shaneé Sumerlin
The prices went way up.
-
November 2023 by Hank Hellen
BYE why was a jacket with holes in it 70$??? WHY THE HUGE UPCHARGE :(
