Casey's in Tomah, WI, located at 313 N Superior Ave, offers a variety of services and products that make it a popular local spot. Known for its delicious pizza made with scratch dough, real mozzarella cheese, and fresh toppings, it provides great delivery and pickup options, including DoorDash. Besides pizza, the store features appetizers, sweet treats, drinks, and a selection of household essentials and groceries. Customers appreciate the friendly staff and the welcoming atmosphere, often mentioning the helpfulness and kindness of employees. The management team, especially the manager and kitchen manager, receive high praise for their hard work and dedication. The staff are described as hardworking, friendly, and generous, with some customers noting moments where staff have gone out of their way to help, even paying for items when customers forget money. The store holds nostalgic value for some, reminding long-time visitors of past memories. While some mention that the store could be cleaner and staff better trained, overall, visitors have a positive experience, especially enjoying the pizza and bakery items. Casey’s is also a place where community and kindness shine through, making it a favorite stop for locals looking for good food, friendly service, and convenience.
The cashier paid for my monster and recently when I keep forgetting about 50 cents to a dollar other people are generous and pay for it. Five stars
September 2023
great food when it's available. Three days in a row no pizza available. The cook wasn't doing anything at the time either. The lady at the register was great as always though.
August 2023
The pizza here is unstoppable!! I doordashed a large pepperoni pizza and the worker, Kathie, made my pizza to perfection! Always a hit! Will continue to order pizza from here!
