-
June 2024 by Sam B
Sun Prairie this is your store for Coins, Silver and Gold.
I have been here Many times and he is extremely fair with prices. DO NOT go to these stores advertised on TV, there is a reason they can AFFORD ADS, they charge way over and pay under spot prices. Don't waste even a phone call.
Just come to Collectors Choice !
-
August 2023 by Another Dilla
John does a great job making guests feel welcomed
-
August 2023 by Kevin Yunto
Treated great built a friendship i think . Great guy great place
-
July 2023 by John Arnold
Very happy to work with John Krueger, he was very helpful and has a great inventory with the best prices I have found.
-
April 2023 by Jimmy McCann
Really interesting shop. Very helpful and friendly for first time coin buyers.
-
September 2022 by Troy Zaspel
This place is great. The owner knows his stuff and is honest and fair.
-
August 2022 by Kathleen Berman
We brought in a box of older coins that belonged to my mother. Tom and Dan were very helpful and explained the value of each coin - and why it was so We sold most of the collection at a very fair price. As a bonus, we met the very sweet onsite dog. Recommend this local store - friendly, honest and knowledgeable. Thanks!
-
July 2022 by Lauren Gilbert
I found John to be kind, honest and fair. He was prompt, provided a detailed estimate, and conducted our transaction in a professional manner.
-
May 2022 by Tony Tiger 777
Owner very knowledgeable on coins. Willing to help and very nice to deal with.
-
May 2022 by Carolyn Moore
Knowledgeable honest and fair will definitely come back again plus they have the world's cutest door greeter
-
April 2022 by Kat T
I walked in with 2 jars of miscellaneous coins and the owner was fast, efficient and able to explain why items were valued at without skipping a beat. Coins aren't my thing but if it's yours, check them out!!My random find in a box was worth way more than I realized!
-
November 2021 by Bryant Davenport
Owner was very knowledgeable and had great prices from entry level to the serious collector. Highly recommend this coin shop if you pass through the Madison area! I know I will be
-
November 2021 by Tony K
I did not get to go ro this place because of a note on the front door stating that the owner was at a coin show...nothing on the website about this or I would not have wasted my time.
-
September 2021 by joel kennedy
Did not go there
-
September 2021 by Troy Burton
From the great reviews alone I'm looking forward to visiting Collector's Choice Coins
