-
March 2024 by Kelly Wollersheim
Vegetarian options: Only salad bar and a vegi toasted sandwich option and sides
-
March 2024 by Nancy Bastjan
Great place for eating and drinks. Friendly staff and food is awesome. Thanks to everyone.
-
March 2024 by Robin Van Duser
Not great. Lettuce was all brown, (and it was full) chicken had no flavor and all breading. The haddock breading fell apart so you couldn’t eat it when you took a bite of fish, but ok. The combo was $24 for that, This was our second time there and we won’t be back.
-
February 2024 by Ali Leon
We picked the Granary for my Birthday dinner based on feedback from friends that live in the area.It proved to be a good recommendation. Being a Thursday night the place wasn't crowded and we could be seated immediately.The atmosphere here is very welcoming and we enjoyed a delicious meal complete with Brandy Alexandars for dessert.This is a stop we will be sure to make again when we are in the area. Extremely cozy dining with exceptionally friendly staff! Thanks again!
-
February 2024 by Douglas Yonke
Good service. Get the early on Saturday if you want some prime rib.
-
January 2024 by Bri B.
Atmosphere: Tight parking lot that was packed to the brim, do not wear your nice shoes ladies if it rains, lots of potholes and gravel. The inside was old school, I'm guessing it's been a hot minute since anything was updated. Single person bathroom so it's a waiting game if you need to go. Service: You place your name with the hostess to be seated when you walk in. It was about a 40 minute wait. They must have been really understaffed because the dining room was half empty when we were seated. After we put our name in I wanted to order a cocktail but when I told the bartender what I wanted to order she said she'd try her best but it wasn't her specialty (it's 3 ingredients?), so I opted for a beer not wanting to shell out the dough for a potentially crappy cocktail. The beer was not cold...choked my way through it and that was enough for drinks for the evening. We ended up going to a different bar down the road for drinks after. Food: You order after you are seated? Which is a first for me at a supper club. I opted out of an entrée because everyone's food looked really heavily breaded and I do not care for thick breading. I instead got the all you can eat soup and salad bar. It was...dismal at best. The soups were empty, the bread was this weird white bread which ripped if you tried to put butter on it because the butter was cold. The salad bar was over half empty and the ingredients were weird (chicken gizzards that were pickled? with at least 10 empty slots you think they'd put things out that everyone would like). Nothing was labeled at the salad bar either, so it was like playing a guessing game of what you were eating or attempting to eat for most of it. The friend I went with gave me a few bites of food off their plate and I'm so glad I did not order an entrée, the fish was dry, the broccoli wasn't seasoned, and the "potato puff" was like deep fried box mashed potatoes? Weirdest experience I've had out in a while....I'm wondering if I just came on a bad night because of all the good reviews? Either way I'm in no rush to come back.
-
January 2024 by Hope Clausnitzer
Got dinner on New Year's Eve, it wasn't very busy we saw our waitress very minimumly, She didn't ask us what we wanted to drink, or check in on us, However we had to ask the other waitress around to grab us some ketchup for the table, We were a large table in the back so we should've had more attention on us and we had and when we got up to leave There was nobody else In the dining area, and only a few people at the bar, definitely would have When a better review if we have been checked on more often.
-
January 2024 by Eric Jones
Scallops Supreme. Excellently prepared.
-
January 2024 by Kaitlin Pohl
Truly the best perch I've had in a long time. Their salad bar is also super fresh and extensive.
-
December 2023 by George Vander Linden
Was here for a Xmas party tonight I had fish that was served chicken and beef tips that was really good.
-
December 2023 by Linda B
Excellent food & and drinks with superb service!
-
December 2023 by Ryan Williamson
In the land of supper clubs this one holds its own. Good food and atmosphere. I especially like the soup and salad bar as it gives you the opportunity to choose what you want rather than getting everything served to you whether you like it or not.We enjoyed looking at the historical photos spread around the bar, as this building speaks to the amazingness and history of Sherwood, Wisconsin.
-
December 2023 by Kyle Kramer
Been coming here as far back as I can remember. Perfect, old school super club. Never in a rush but they always seat you quick given how busy they can get. Great food and salad bar and incredibly affordable. Best
-
November 2023 by Nakyta Chentis
The Granary Supper Club offered a simple well put together menu in a relaxing and inviting atmosphere the drinks were amazing the muddled old fashion was excellent and a Wis staple! We had roast duck over rice phailf and prime rib both were seasoned to perfection and had excellent flavor! Will definitely be coming back to try more! Oh and the soup and salad bar with the warm bread top it off!
-
November 2023 by Tamara Shortess
Every time we are here, the food is wonderful, service from these young ladies is amazing, and we are never disappointed in anything!
