-
April 2024 by Collin D.
I've just recently started working with Andy and I have nothing, but positive feedback. Honest, transparent and passionate are perhaps the words most befitting. In this hobby and/or "business", there is a lot of deception, smoke and mirrors, and flat out unethical behavior. However, people like Andy are the most redeeming individuals to help quell this truism . His professionalism is a quality that sets him above all else. Andy is an effective commmunicator and a highly competent numismatist. I look at the negative reviews and scoff slightly, because nothing could be farther from the truth. A simple email or phone call will confirm all that I've said. But don't trust me, go ahead and see for yourself. I truly believe that you will be amazed at what amount of humanity and morality exist in the numismatic space and a large part is thanks to Andy. Good day to you sir
-
October 2023 by Caleb Reifer
Called the place and talked with someone about some coins. And he was completely honest and gave me a range of options. Also very very nice over the phone
-
September 2023 by Mike K.
Andy is the most knowledgeable and professional numismatist in SE WI. His passion for coins and helping his customers is exactly what any collector will enjoy.Mike Kin
-
August 2023 by DB PC
One of the best coin dealers around. Andrew gives me an education and helps me pick out great coins for my collection. I’ve been buying coins most of my life and I feel privileged to be able to work with Andrew.
-
August 2023 by Beth Hodorowski
I am new to coin collecting and the moment that I walked in the door Andrew greeted me with enthusiasm and spent a lot of time educating me on coin collecting rather than trying to sell me anything. As a new coin collector he helped me out and I look forward to doing business with him in the future.Thank you so much Andrew,Sawyer
-
July 2023 by richard melamed
Extremely honest gold, silver, and rare coin buyer. I would highly recommend Andy!
-
April 2023 by John Schroder
I very rarely give reviews but I definitely want to do so today. I am a relative novice and pauper in regards to numismatics. I went to Paragon recently to have some coins appraised. Andy treated me like royalty during the almost one hour I spent with him. He explained various aspects of my coins in easy to understand terminology. I truly believe he was more interested in educating me and encouraging an appreciation for numismatics than trying to sell me something. A great experience. Thank you Andy!
-
November 2022 by Boz
I met Andrew at a Milwaukee coin show. I didn’t end up purchasing anything from him, but Andrew was super nice and helpful, and ended up giving me tons of good advice. He’s absolutely someone I would do business with in the future.
-
December 2021 by Ken Zinkgraf
Andy was friendly, explained how he determined the price for an item, and provided with me a competitive price.
-
March 2021 by Mike Kin
When you go from coin collector to a true student of numismatics go see Andy.
-
March 2021 by Earl S.
I've bought and sold a number of coins from Andy over the years. He is very knowledgeable and fair when it comes to his coins. I learn something new every time I visit him. I've referred several people to him regarding collections and everyone felt he gave them a fair appraisal and price.
-
June 2020 by Josh Terry
Great coin dealer. Deals in mostly high end coins.
-
December 2019 by Coin P.
Andy is a knowledgeable coin buyer and seller with his own unique style that one might not initially expect upon first experience with Paragon Numismatics. His interesting philosophies and perspectives on the hobby make him someone worth talking to if you are the kind of person who appreciates a good numismatic conversation. I don't believe him to be any less reputable than other local dealers, but a sometimes outspoken guy with personality. His inventory is usually pretty cool since I think one of his strengths is purchasing and then selling highly collectable coins.
-
December 2019 by C Fenzl
Andy is a great guy. He went through my case of coins and explained the process. I walked away with a check in hand. He really knows his stuff. Thank you Andy for all your help. I will be sharing your contact info with anyone looking for help with their coins, silver or gold collections.
-
November 2019 by Derek Allen
I made my first silver purchase today at Paragon Numismatics. Andrew is FUN to work with. Andrew gave me very focused attention (both on the phone and in person), he educated me, and he is very ethical. I will be a returning customer. Thank you Andrew!
