Mr. P's Tires is a locally-owned business in Milwaukee, proudly serving the community for over 30 years with five convenient locations. The shop is known for its great pricing, knowledgeable staff, and efficient service. Customers appreciate the no-appointment, first-come, first-served policy, which allows for quick tire repairs and replacements. Many reviews highlight the friendly and patient staff who provide helpful assistance without pushing for unnecessary services. While some customers noted unprofessional behavior from staff members during busy times, the majority praised the swift and effective service. Whether it's fixing a flat tire or providing new tires unexpectedly, Mr. P's Tires has built a reputation for being reliable and affordable. Customers have shared experiences of being in and out within hours, often receiving lower prices than competitors. The atmosphere may be a bit rough around the edges, but the focus remains on providing excellent tire services promptly. For anyone needing tire assistance in Milwaukee, Mr. P's Tires is highly recommended for its straightforward approach and commitment to customer satisfaction.
I’ve been going there for years and they never done wrong by me. Probably the best place to go for tires anywhere in metro Milwaukee. I will definitely keep coming back.
December 2025
Get there early because they get busy as soon as they open. They carry most sizes in popular brands and will order anything they don't carry. Prices have been lower than other tire chains. Can also replace tire pressure sensors.
November 2025
Great experience. Parking is limited & that is a pain. Great service, competitive prices and fairly quick!
