Convenience Stores near Fish Creek, WI

“Stopped to fuel up the truck and get some windshield washer fluid. Owner gave me a few paper funnels so I wouldn't spill while filling the windshield washer container. Very nice of him. Always great service at this BP!”

“Stopped here for fuel and snacks and have to mention these homemade Amish Fried pies.They are kind of like a turnover, or similar to a Hostess pie, but much better. Homemade and fresh, they are served in wax paper pouch like the old days, instead of plastic or vacuum sealed packaging.We tried coconut cream and it was excellent. I wanted to try the other flavors but unfortunately we already had cherry pie and Uncle Mike's Kringle waiting for us and didn't want to stack too many desserts”

“The only place in Bailey's Harbor to get basic groceries and gasoline. Even so, prices are reasonable. It's bigger inside than appears on the outside.”

“This Shell convenience store/station sits right on a prime scenic lot on Highway 42 overlooking the bay. I couldn't believe that they had the same $3.899/gal price for regular 87 octane that matched the cheapest price anywhere in Door County at this time. I've seen Shell prices at a lot of places over the years in both the US and overseas, and they're ALWAYS one of the highest priced brands, ha. I had to fill up here just for grins, even though I really didn't need to. It was an old style pump too, with no card reader, no digital screens, and I was flabbergasted and paralyzed for a moment! I thought, well, I guess have to go in and give them my credit card for a prepayment. But nope, Andrea the clerk inside, just says fill it up and come back and tell me how much it was. Ha, a total old school honor system here, and a nostalgic trip to the past. I'll go with 4 stars. Now if they had an attendant come out and check my oil dipstick and clean the windshield and pump the gas, I'd go with 5 stars 4sure! ps - Inside the building, they have a standard, small convenience store with pre-packaged goods, i.e., no hot food.”