-
September 2023 by Brenda K.
Absolutely the BEST caramel apples. They are always fresh! I ship them to my daughter living out of state. It's one of the few places that has caramel apples year round. I haven't tried the other candy, but everything looks and smells amazing
-
September 2023 by Janice M.
I travel to Cedarburg about 2x/year. Knowing I was going, I was excited to get a cashew milk chocolate turtle apple. Went to Amy's and ordered the apple along with 2 separate chocolate candies. The clerk asked me several times what kind of candies I wanted and what kind of apple. I thought to myself, how many times do I need to tell her. The following day I opened my apple box only to find it was not the apple that I ordered. I was so disappointed. It was a pecan apple. I called the customer service line and explained the situation to someone who said she only handles business orders and then asked me if I had the receipt and also asked if the apple was eaten. I did not have the receipt (but again I paid with a cc so they should be able to see my charge) and yes, my spouse ended up eating the apple (did the clerk want me to throw it out?). She then stated she would pass my concern on to the store and look for my cc purchase and that she would get back to me. This never happened and I was completely ghosted. Will not go back!!! Considering you charge $11 per apple, you should treat your customers like gold!!
-
August 2023 by Lee D.
Yelp check-in 10% off, see picture.Quality/Quantity - My daughter loves caramel apples, but at the last second she decided not to get another one. We got her one yesterday.Atmosphere - Small to-go place. All the candies look so fresh and good!Open kitchen/bakery.Open 7 days a week from 9am to 8pm, open Sundays from 10am to 7pm.Service - Good.Price - Above average, but you have to pay for quality.Owner Comment - Congrats on your success since 1996.
-
July 2023 by Borneo G.
OMG. This place always smells amazing and the chocolate is so freaking good here. Every time I visit my in-laws in Wisconsin I make it a point to stop here because I cannot find a place in California that has chocolate covered pretzel rods that are nearly as good as this place. I wish this store would sell these pretzel rods online because I would buy at least 10 of them and ship them to my house.Definitely recommend this place, highly. I can't wait to come back here again the next time I'm in town!
-
July 2023 by Michael T.
Excellent. I will definitely return. Their caramel apples are fantastic. Really. The caramel is softer, like a real caramel candy, not overly sweet and they use Granny Smith apples, an excellent choice. They use lightly salted pecans on one, so you get a wonderful balance sweet and salty. Their pricing is surprisingly reasonable. At the time of this review, a plain caramel apple was $8.50, and I feel it was certainly worth it. They box them very nicely, so they travel well and make excellent gifts. (See my photos for what they look like.) If you are not certain, but one, try it and see for yourself. You will probably immediately realize you will want more.
-
July 2023 by Chris W.
This place has really gone down hill in the last few years. The caramel consistency is softer and not as sweet. It's like caramel sauce. The apple itself has been hit or miss as far as flavor and the customer service is lacking when they make a mistake with your purchase. The apples are over priced too. I think they have a new owner because it's just not the same. Sadly I do not recommend this place anymore.
-
January 2023 by Liz K.
best. caramel. i've. ever. had!!! if you have one stop in cedarberg, this is it! my family and I have gone here for the past few years and it definitely deserves the credit! their specialty caramel apples in fall are also the best ones i've had! the staff goes above and beyond and i've never left disappointed. also the pecan turtles are my all time favorite sweet so I suggest it be one of the first things you get! it may be different if crowded, but worth the wait! 5/5!!!
-
November 2022 by Jerilyn A.
Fall means Carmel apples! Amy's has really great apples and I make it a point to come every fall. The apples are big and shareable and the Carmel is super tasty. They have a variety of apples with different things on them. They also have candy and other treats. On this stop I noticed they had some festive candies for sale.
-
August 2022 by C J.
The candy is pretty good but way overpriced. The apples and fairy food were tasty and delicious. Some of the candy is just re-bagged with their logo on it. Like a small bag of Jolly Ranchers for $4.00.
-
April 2022 by Da G.
This place is great...and it certainly is not your average store bought chocolate and candy. You will pay a little more, but it is REALLY GOOD chocolate! You can get many of their caramel apples for $10.00 or less, and each comes in its own box. While the youngsters will go nuts (no pun intended) over the ones bedazzled with nuts, chips and colored candy and jimmies, there are plenty of regular dipped ones to make a trip here worth your while. Try the salted caramel in either the milk or dark. Its worth waiting if there is a line out the door on weekends!
-
November 2021 by Kimberly G.
Amy's candy is an incredible business if you ever have the chance to be in Cedarburg Wisconsin you must go. Not only are the apples incredible but the candy is awesome as well. It's all homemade. Everything is awesome. Can't say enough about them. Have a great time!
-
June 2021 by Valerie M.
Seriously if you are in the area go! They have something for everyone, from smaller treats to basically every kind of Carmel apple concoction you could think of! Staff is always friendly and ready to help, I recommend trying the apple pie Carmel apple, it's amazing!
-
June 2021 by Annoyed I.
AMAZING!! Last Fall, at the urging of several relatives, we visited Cedarburg for the sole purpose of experiencing Amy's Candy Kitchen. Our family has a sweet tooth and Amy's did not disappoint!! The selection of Gourmet Caramel Apples is nearly unending. Amy's Apples are the perfect pairing of tart and sweet which make them not only a treat but an ideal gifting option. Amy's is now my go-to establishment for any and all types of celebrations. If you are near Cedarburg, Amy's Candy Kitchen is a MUST! If you are not, you can always utilize their online services. I believe I am currently on my 8th order. WARNING: These ARE addicting!!
-
May 2021 by Jan B.
My husband and I stopped in there after dinner in Cedarburg. I purchased a half a pound of toffee at 3350 a pound, and one apple. The Toffie was disgusting it's stuck to her teeth, not crunchy as you would expect toffee to be. And the apple with Amelia inside. I called the company and after several conversations with them they could not find my order. We gave them The date, the approximate time we were there and amazingly they could not find our order. Not through cash purchases North through debit card purchases. They told me there is no way the Apple could've been Meleon side but it was, and that that's the way they make their toffee. That is untrue as I have had both are apples and their toffee before. So after an approximate $30 purchase they refuse to give me my money back. Unless you like toffee that absolutely sticks to your teeth and Miele afterwards, I would not suggest purchasing from them anymore
-
March 2021 by Rhonda F.
Oh Amy's Candy Kitchen - what have you done to me?!?! I cannot stop thinking about my caramel apple... While visiting Cedarburg, we passed Amy's as we walked along the main street for shopping and dining. So of course we stopped in twice because once was not good enough. The gorgeous apples called my name every time I walked by. The candies look lovingly made. So many choices for every taste and craving. I had my eye on the caramel apples as there were sooo many varieties. I settled on a salted caramel version that was much better than I expected. The creamy caramel with a hint of sea salt over a crisp delicious apple really set me off. Every bite was perfection. My friend enjoyed her apple with caramel and peanuts and also bought some beautiful Easter milk chocolates that she loved. Everything is so adorable in this cute spot. It feels like an old fashioned sweets shop from back in the day. The young girls working were so sweet and helpful. It was busy and they assisted everyone easily. I swear those taffy apples might cause me to move to Cedarburg!!!
