-
November 2023 by David Wielochowski
honest and great place to purchase your coins from, ben is very knowledgeable and a very nice person.
-
September 2023 by Justyn Szucs
Wishing I could give them 10 stars. These guys are the best. Fair prices/offers. Great communication. Ben is truly amazing and the young lady who expedites all guests who walk through their doors. Even if you question yourself of what you have, bring it here and they will be your best option out there. Keep up the great work guys
-
August 2023 by Ambrea DiMaggio
Huge Selection! Excellent Values! Honest & Intelligent! This shop never disappoints and always exceeds expectations.
-
July 2023 by Matthew Walker
Small place good help but bony really a good deal . Now don’t get me wrong I could just have common coins
-
July 2023 by Jacob Woyahn
I want to thank Greater Milwaukee Coin and especially the wonderful woman that helped me today. She took the time to explain to me and help me understand what I was looking at and looking for. I never ever felt like I was wasting any of her time and answered every question I had. Thank youdefinitely be back and let everyone know how great
-
July 2023 by Amanda Zarder
The original owners, Russ and Ken, were staples in the local coin community; however, there are new owners now. When the store was reopening, I brought in a few coins and a small amount of gold in to sell.A few of my items were not really looked at, but they passed on the coins that they did take a look at. The offer on the gold ring was also a bit on the low side compared to another shop’s offer at the time, although to be fair it was a small amount of gold for a new shop to buy and might not have been worth the time for them. The staff here was certainly not rude and were quite polite, but we were unable to make a deal. I ended up going to another shop in town and getting more than my ask on my coins.Just my personal experience with the new shop, so I figured I should update my review.
-
June 2023 by Stephanie Spier
What a great experience I had here! I can't say for sure that I'll be back because I was passing through on vacation, but the staff helping me was so kind, thoughtful, and accommodating. I wish they were in my neighborhood!
-
June 2023 by David Schoen
Friendly people with a ton of knowledge and professionalism. I will definitely return for future business.
-
May 2023 by Dustin Ickow
Fair & Knowledgeable on the buy and sell side. Don't hesitate to do business with Greater Milwaukee Coin.
-
March 2023 by Bessie Crum
Great shop. Quality products and people. New owner Ben really knows his stuff. Selling gold and silver bars and coins. Buying coins and paper money. Great team working here. Will be back!
-
February 2023 by Michael Pulice
It's a small place if you get four people in there it's already ? crowded. The display cases are ok but if they don't limit the amount of customers it is hard to see anything ? and the plexiglass is so tall there it's like being in a prison also I heard they are closing that place. P.S. the workers are very nice and helpful.
-
January 2023 by Lisa Maertz
Ken was amazing, he knows his stuff, I recommend him for any coins you want looked at!!
-
September 2022 by Justin K.
Hands down Ken the owner and everyone working at this place are the best in the business they are the only place in the area that I purchased from and will only ever best prices best service highest price is paid if you are selling lowest prices if you are buying a visit them a few times a week the Brookfield store and the Waukesha store they are simply the best in the business you guys rock! Sincerely John Jacob Jingleheimer Schmidt a.k.a. Justin
-
September 2022 by Robyn Shepard
This is the place to go. I had several items I wanted to sell and after reading reviews I am so grateful I went here. I got there as much before close as I could and all the staff/owner were so kind to me. They helped me understand what I had, when it was from, and offered top amount. They are kind to work with and if you decide you don’t want to sell an item they are supportive. Very grateful to have found this location. The owner did tell me that if you are looking to trade or apply credit for jewelry then you should go to the Waukesha location because they offer a full jewelry store and have the ability to order pieces.
-
August 2022 by Josue Ordaz
Staff was Super friendly Selection was prime here. I asked to look at some things & without hesitation I had it in my hand. Asked to take photos of items and here they are o definitely recommend this place.
