-
January 2024 by Bill Bussler
Stopped here for lunch with a local that I was working with that day. I am still fairly new to the pepperoni rolls, not being from this area. I've had several now from several places and the one I got here is BY FAR the best I've had. Fresh right out of the oven....it was delicious! And the price for two people was amazing. I wish I had reason to be in West Milford more often, I'd be here alot!
-
December 2023 by Steven and Danielle Bennett Bennett
Friendly employees good prices and the chicken sub is amazing I love there food!!
-
November 2023 by Marcus McManus
BUY THE PEPPERONI ROLLS
-
September 2023 by Chastity Walker Millikin
Nice country store, fishing bait available and deli too
-
August 2023 by Chastity Millikin
Lots of options, as it's secluded
-
May 2023 by Angie Thalheim
First time ordered pizza from there for 3 pizzas amazing and better then Papa John's or dominoes will be return customer
-
January 2023 by Trish White
Food is amazing but one employee feels it’s ok to attack customers. She’s been let go but they always bring her back. Last episode was last night she attacked a lady while her kids watched from the car. The 13 and 7 year old came to their mothers rescue the aggressors daughter is apparently use to this ridiculous behavior because she was also present and tried to comfort the 7 year old. All of the other employees are wonderful just one bad apple is spoiling it for the good ones. Very disappointed
-
December 2022 by Larry Stout
Love it and the food is awesome
-
July 2022 by Tammy Rector
I love the little restaurant. The food is amazing. (especially the pepperoni rolls)
-
April 2022 by Sierra Davisson-fultineer
We LOVE The Diner! Everything they make is fresh and delicious! Anytime someone asks me where they can find the best hoagies, best Giovanni's, best salads and best fresh pepperoni rolls I send them here! When we lived closer (Laurel valley) we ate here at least once a week. We still venture that way when we don't feel like cooking but want something that tastes home made and burnt out on fast food. I've never left disappointed! Even when I ran the register at the store year ago I still didn't get sick of the food which usually happens when we work on a restaurant! I've always got along with all the employees too and they have been very friendly, accommodating, and down to earth. The restaurant/store has that old school family and friends/ma and pa type feeling that's hard to find these days but still have updated products. I will always be a loyal customer as long as you keep serving that great food and great service ?
-
November 2021 by Sp Ud
Wow this is THE best gas station restaurant ive eaten at and ive been to alot in my life!!! Their THE WORKS caulzone is to die for!! The staff was very polite and respectful!! Service and speed was excellent!! Thank you kind ladys for a great first experience of eating in your restaurant!! I highly recommended eating here! I will for sure be back!!!
-
August 2021 by Jenny Morgan
Amazing place with amazing employees and service. Really wish you had a menu on here though, even if you put on that it is subject to change.
-
April 2021 by Curtis Marozzi
Got the apple pork today with potatoes. Tender, thick and absolutely amazing. Barb did an awesome job. Staff is always good to me there.
-
April 2021 by Dona Scarff
Great food called for 20 mins with no answer though
-
July 2020 by Andrew L. Opyoke III
Everyone is great! The foods is delicious and the staff are friendly!
