Jewelry Stores in Puyallup, WA

“listen- the guy knows what he’s talking about. point blank period. i’ve worked with so many different piercers (many in puyallup) and at this point, matt and angelo ARE THE ONLY ONES ill let near me with a needle.

i didn’t realize i was getting so much misinformation and bad piercing jobs done until he clarified so much for me with facts.

they won’t paint you a pretty picture, he won’t talk to you through rose colored glasses but they will give you the cold hard facts and keep it 100% real with you. after the experiences i’ve had at other places, they will be the only ones i trust from now on.

this man is passionate about what he does and just knows his stuff. he values quality jewelry (i previously thought i was getting quality jewelry at the other places in puyallup/tacoma areas i had tried) until i learned there is a huge difference.

i could’ve saved myself so much trouble and issues if i had just worked with them from the get go. not everyone that owns a shop knows what they’re doing. save yourself the trouble i went through in having bad piercing jobs removed & just go here from the get go tbh. wish i had known is all i can rly say.

to matt and angelo, from the deepest part of me, thank you so much. you guys were phenomenal. words can’t do you both true justice”

“My experience here is always amazing. Even when I come in with a ton of stuff, they never disappoint and test everything. ♥️ highest price for gold and silver ?”

“I was looking to get my engagement ring and high school promise ring combined into a wedding band set. I also had a set of earrings to match my promise ring and unfortunately lost one of the earrings. So I wanted it turned into a necklace. I went to google and found Je. She was fabulous from the moment we met to working together on the entire process. I felt she really cared about my idea coming together and with my vision. She kept me update through the entire process. I will recommend her to everyone I know.”

“Erin was absolutely awesome. She will try her hardest to give you exactly what you want. She doesn't give up. I felt very at ease with her and that's not a common occurrence for me.”

“Absolutely phenomenal service all around!! Their customer service was fantastic, they were extremely gracious anytime i called for an update. They made sure the ring was in perfect condition before pickup, including what couldn’t be seen by the eyes. The quality of the gold, diamonds, and settings are superb. It was a unique experience designing the ring and picking out the diamond. This is truly a small family run business and it’s apparent how much love and care is put into their work.”

“Got my Septum piercing here that I've been wanting since forever. The ladies at the front desk were super sweet and chatted with us for a while and let us complain to them about how hard it was at other places to get it, it was really nice. The guy who did the piercing was super sweet as well, he was very quick and gentle, it didn't really hurt at all, great service! I love the piercing so much and I'm glad all the staff was kind and fun to talk to. 10/10 would definitely and will definitely recommend.”

“I am writing this to give A HUGE shoutout to the sales associate by the name of Amanda at the S Hill Mall Kay Jewelers! I bought my favorite ring back in 2004 with a Lifetime sizing and Diamond warranty. Well I went in to have my ring resized at least 2 years ago on a few occasions and the associate at those times couldn’t find any record of my ring! Mind you I had to have it inspected and a diamond replaced so yes there was a record but absolutely NO ONE on any of the visits could find it! Well today I thought I would try again and within a half hour Amanda found my rings records! I cannot thank her enough as this ring is very special to me and with her going the extra mile of research and looking I will finally be wearing my beautiful ring again once it gets sized down a size! It is employees like her that truly make me feel that there are individuals who care about their customers as the others could have cared less and this was really my last attempt!! Thank you Amanda and I hope they appreciate the work you do!!”

“Tony and team are fantastic, knowledgeable and honest. They always give the best price and though their inventory to purchase is not huge, that is not my primary reason for visiting them. I imagine that keeping inventory on items for sale lower allows him to have more flexibility in his offers to purchase.”

“Excellent Service! One of the ladies helped me pick out the perfect graduation gift for our niece, and another gentleman and lady helped me check out for my half day watch repair turn around! This is my spot for all my jewelry needs! Thank you!”

“I just want to say, Alexis was absolutely amazing! I came in complaining about my current wedding ring. It's been through a lot and I'm looking to upgrade to a completely new piece. She was so patient, so sweet and knowledgeable. Aside from discussing a new piece, she made me feel so good about my current ring and spoke of the sentimental value it holds. She was just awesome! Oh and she cleaned my current ring and my goodness, she gave it life again! I'll be back! Thanks Alexis!”

“We just got our 7th month old baby girl’s ears pierced at the south hill mall and Mikayla was absolute amazing!! She was patient with our little one and even my other daughter as well who was not even getting her ears pierced! Highly recommend?”

“I have been doing business with them for years and each and every time they have been wonderful. Since my health has declined to where I can hardly walk. As soon as I enter the store someone is rushing to get me a chair and make me as comfortable as possible while business is taken care of. Each and every person that works there that I've interacted with in any way have been so helpful, willing to answer however many questions or help me retain my pawned items as due dates approach or get the best deal possible when I make a purchase. I absolutely love the people, store, and entire experience each and every time I stop in!”