-
January 2024 by April Dorgan
After a long drive from our house we were looking for food. Found this hidden gem just down the street from our Airbnb. The food is amazing. My husband ordered the BLT and I ordered the Brooklyn Cuban sandwich and boy it took me back to my days living in Key West FL where you can get a true Cuban sandwich. We will definitely come back.
-
January 2024 by Joshua Winslow
Everything about this place is wonderful - incredible sandwiches, soups, baked goods - all local!Art too!The soup today blew my mind, don’t even know how to describe it but don’t sleep on this place.
-
October 2023 by Angela Dong
Super tasty food, lovely staff, clean and cozy restaurant with local artists' pieces, and a great drinks selection! Highly recommend this place and grateful to be so close to it :) They also have local groceries like eggs, milk, and dips from the nearby farm. Definitely check out this hidden gem!P.S. Highly recommend their breakfast burritos, they are absolutely out of this world, so are their quiches and sandwiches!
-
September 2023 by Patrick Critzer
Absolutely delicious! Burgers, bakery, brownies, breakfast. All the best b words.Local products all over the place. Including fancy socks!They have a dog rescue kiosk station too!Amazing place, stop by!
-
September 2023 by Theresa Langlois
On our way to Walton's Mountian and was looking for a place to eat. Saw a firetruck parked on the side of the road. Realized it was a little quaint place to eat. If the firemen are eating there then you know it is good. Went up the road and turned around. Best darn decision we made. The food and atmosphere was awesome!!! Everything is made to order and fresh. Loved this place. If we are ever in this area again, we will definitely stop!!!!
-
August 2023 by Terry Tereska
Great stop! Nice store but the charm is the food. Locally sourced veggies enhanced already great sandwichs. Go to place when in area!
-
July 2023 by Ren Angle
Went to Polly’s Folly for the first time today! The place is awesome! Mike made me the best burger I have had in a long time. Their pricing is more than reasonable. Mike and his brother Rob took time out to talk with me. I was headed to Pippin Hill Fatm. I told the staff there how great it was and they agreed, they all visit Polly’s Folly on the way to work! So glad I stopped by! Will visit again!
-
July 2023 by Jc Galiana
Fantastic little county store. Mike, the chef, is dedicated to simple good foodA lot of items to shop for. Local items and from far away (Haiti).Recommend the amazing quiches.
-
July 2023 by Stan York
Tiny place, three tables inside and some outside.Surprisingly tasty pastrami sandwich. Some surprising beverage choices.Clean restroom.
-
June 2023 by Andrew Gallagher
I travel for work and love finding small privately owned stores and restaurants, and I’ve got to say that after spending time in 38 states this one is hands down without a shadow of a doubt my favorite. Over the course of a couple weeks my co-workers and I must have tried every item on the menu and none of us ever left the table less than 100% satisfied. If it was possible to give more stars than 5 I absolutely would. Mike and his staff are incredible, and they really make you feel appreciated. Whether you’re passing through or sticking around for a while I highly recommend you make a pit stop for a delicious lunch and a maybe a little locally sourced goods shopping. Best of luck to Polly’s Folly and I can only hope I get the chance to stop again someday!
-
June 2023 by Ronnie Vance
Such a cool spot and one of the best Burgers I’ve ever had. A must stop spot!
-
June 2023 by Barry W.
Fantastic breakfast sandwiches!!! Great service and super friendly. Highly recommend!
-
May 2023 by Jason Kim
Incredible amazing food, incredible vibes, super friendly and charismatic staff. Me and a friend were starving when we found this spot on our road trip, and it was a gift from God. Cheap, delicious, and local, this is truly the sort of spot you cannot pass by. 5 stars, would give 6 if I could
-
May 2023 by Trish M.
This place was such a treat during our cabin stay in Schuyler! Mike and Kat were the most generous hosts - preparing a delicious breakfast for us (griddle-style pancakes, hash browns with rosemary, and a fully loaded breakfast burrito), helping me find the best rough rock for our grown son (a geologist), and packaging a quiche breakfast for us to eat in the morning before hitting the road. Polly's Folly carries art by many local artisans, and folks with a keen eye for treasures, including Mike himself who sold me an old, beautiful blue glass bottle he found. At checkout, Mike very generously handed me a small set of "devil's dice," a gift for our son, who deeply appreciates locally-found rocks and gems. After taking off, I decided to pull over and draft this post before losing service. This is a must-visit on any of your travels!
-
May 2023 by Nadia Guida
The best brie and peach slaw sandwich a girl could ask for. Polly's Folly is an incredibly charming shop filled with local products.
