-
August 2024 by Erin Ecker
Very cute produce shop with incredibly friendly and helpful owners. Their tomato pie is the highlight of our year. Call and order a couple days ahead, you won’t be disappointed.
-
August 2024 by J R
Stopped here after a movie in town. It was a cute and quirky place. The food was outstanding! We got the tomato pies and fruit pies and they were excellent! Definitely worth the stop.
-
July 2024 by Cody Schwartz
First and last time coming in here.
The lady at the front counter was beyond helpful and very friendly, but the old man had an issue with me petting their dog.
They have a dog that they allow to range around the store / bakery, and I was berated by this old man for petting the dog. So sorry!
If you have this issue with pets, maybe put a up a gate so that the issue doesn’t occur in the future, instead of angrily lashing out at customers.
What a terrible person.
-
July 2024 by Mary McCarthy
Love this place! Yummy produce (the corn was so good this year) AMAZING pies (Order the pies ahead of time),my favorite is Blueberry and fun vintage finds. Cool crafts and gorgeous wood sculptures too.
I like to get their eggs too, if you are lucky you’ll get the colorful ones, about 4-5 different colors and so fresh!
-
July 2024 by Alice Revere
Excellent fresh produce. Super sweet staff.
-
July 2024 by Jake McGlothin
This place was a pleasant surprise. Got the cherry berry pie and was blown away. Not too sweet, lots of different berries. The owners were lovely. The word on the street is that they have excellent savory pies. Maybe next time!
-
June 2024 by Dana Smith
OMG the pies!! Purchased a sour cherry, and a chocolate pecan pie for a family dinner. Everyone loved them. So delicious.
-
June 2024 by Allison Reynolds
Great produce and farm fresh eggs from the owners kids helping raising chickens love it support small family businesses!
-
June 2024 by Caitlin Schein
Tomato pie is amazing! Everything else is great too, but you have to try the tomato pie.
-
June 2024 by No Name
On our Holiday we picked up a tomato pie for departure day breakfast. Amazing! Warm it in the oven wrapped in foil, on 250° for an hour.
We went back on departure day to grab one of the two mixed berry pies she had made that day. Amazing!
-
June 2024 by Amanda Gunther
This is an island MUST!!! The Tomato Pie is extraordinary. So fresh! So tomato-y! So basil-y! You have to order a day ahead but sometimes they have the pies on the counter. D-E-L-I-C-I-O-U-S. It's an island staple like the Creamery or those pastries at Amarin.
-
September 2023 by Ben Loomis
The local fresh figs were the highlight of our first visit to Church Street Produce. These trees seem to grow very happily on Chincoteague island.We ordered a Tomato Pie to see how it may be different than what we get in Norristown, PA. As you can see in the pictures, the Tomato Pie had a nice flakey crust with a savory filling of delicious fresh tomatoes and a nice blend of Italian spices with a generous layer of cheese then baked. We received a text message that our Tomato Pie was done and we showed up promptly to find the friendly staff pulling our pie from the oven. We took it to our home for the week and enjoyed it right away while it was still hot from the oven. I assumed that my child, who stays well away from stewed tomatoes, to my surprise, really liked CSP's Tomato Pie.From the establishment name, I expected produce, so was pleasantly surprised to find an eclectic assortment of gift items, including handmade jewelry, while the produce selection was somewhat limited.Well worth checking out when on the island!
-
August 2023 by Carolann Molloy Coffey
We just bought our 1st Tomato Pie. We got back to our rental place and tried it. It was devoured in less than 10 minutes! A vacation on Chincoteague Island is not complete until you’ve had this pie!! It was out of this world delicious!! We will be back JUST to get this pie again! Coming from Long Island food snobs - don’t miss this place!
-
August 2023 by Barry LaFreniere
The pie is outstanding. The staff is very friendly. Thanks!!
-
August 2023 by Yun S.
Paula and Jerry and some of the nicest people you'll come across on Chincoteague. Paula makes the most delicious fruit pies and Jerry is the mastery behind the tomato pies. Neither of the pies lasted long with my family. If visiting the island, do yourself a favor and stop in to place and order, you can call them as well. The pies are no frills straight up simple ingredients, it's all in the natural flavors of the fruit and delicious crust. I can't say enough about this gem of a find! 10 out of 10!!
