-
March 2024 by Reuven Zecharia
Good Parms. Nice service. Warm people. WILL return hopefully.Vegetarian options: Parm Eggplant. Pizza, cheese.Parking: Lots of spots in a spacious lot.
-
March 2024 by larry fisher (leftwardcoma048)
we orders 3 pizza and thay are so thin and topping sucked you can look right through it and see the crust it never used to be like that
-
March 2024 by Andrea A.
Best pizza I have had in this area so far. We ate in the dining area and it was very clean and comfortable. The server was very friendly and attentive. I only wish I found this place sooner!
-
March 2024 by Michael Kavanaugh
It's a bit expensive for the portions you get. And said they have VT mac and cheese and it's a very poor cheese sauce not any vermont cheese I've ever had. Other than that it's ok if your very hungry and they do have alot of choices to pick from.
-
February 2024 by Brandon Wilson
Bring back the athens burger
-
January 2024 by Alexis Harris
Great food at a reasonable price. Very accommodating and the dining room is clean and comfortable. Friendly staff. Many options. There is something for everyone.
-
January 2024 by holly carrier
Very slow service and not friendly
-
December 2023 by Mitchell Pike
Amazing
-
December 2023 by Matt Wadelton
Placed an online order as I often do, was called back and told there was no driver available to come to where I live which is no big deal as I do live pretty far and they have to cancel the order, no worries. I had paid via my cash app debit card and the charge was "pending" for a few days then Athens still took my money so the first time I called I had politely asked to speak to a manager on staff about my refund and was told there isn't a manager on staff for that day but that they'd take my name and number down to have the manager call me, a whole day passes and no call back but I figured they got busy or just fell to the wayside so I called back today to try and speak to a manager, when the young woman answered I politely said that I'd like to speak to whatever leadership is on duty and was rudely and bluntly asked "who's this" so I gave my name again and communicated my issue with being charged for a cancelled order and was told verbatim "ummm the lady who does the online refunds comes in liiiiike once a week or something so after she does it it'll go back to our 3rd party ordering app and then you'll have to wait until they do it"Was never told who this manager who handles the refunds is, was never told an estimated time until I get my money back, was left more confused than when I called.Also, as a restaurant who cancels my order (once again no big deal stuff happens), why would you still charge my debit card? I'm having a really difficult time getting a hold of someone who can give me solid information and at the very least get my money back.Otherwise they have decent food and the only place outside of WNY with pizza logs that I've seen so that's cool.
-
December 2023 by Heath Monette
I ordered a steak and cheese calzone with pickles and mayo they brought me a sub, remade it brought it back and didn't even have mayo on the inside like I asked for it was put on the side. Everytime I order from Athens my order is messed up everytime and the staff don't even let Sara know so she says. What happened to the costumers always right not in there case. Not halt at all that place has gone down hill so badly. You pick up the calzone and it just falls apart it's very messy. Things were much better when Rich was there so the time. Took me 80 minutes from the time my order was called in to have it delivered. I called and was out right on hold wasn't even asked if I could hold never even said a word just picked up the phone and put me right on hold. That place is running into the ground. But when they read this they will blame me and not take responsibility for there actions. Worst pizza place in town now
-
December 2023 by Amber
I've been here several times over the years, after this recent visit we will not be returning, waited an hour And the place was pretty much empty,our food when we finally got it was all cold! Food wasn't any good at all very very disappointedCompletely messed up our food, asked for a sausage grinder with onion no peppers.. What we get is thinly sliced pieces of rubber (sausage) with so much fat in it..also raw onions and PEPPERS! I've never in my life seen a place not cook the onions! Also ordered the chicken gyro plate... Again cold and never in my life seen a gyro with just the pita and chicken! No sauce no veggies NOTHING! spaghetti had no flavor sauce was bland and watery absolutely a horrible experience and will not return! Waste of time and money whoever they have cooking there needs to be fired and they need a new cooking crew! These people have no idea what they are doing! And are the slowest cooks I've ever seen! A hour for food when the place was empty? And when we get it its all ice cold? Ridiculous!
-
November 2023 by Sara Gagnon
A lot people standing around behind the counter. Not much actual help.
-
November 2023 by Nicholas R
Placed an online order and the estimated time for pickup was 1 hour. When I got there an hour later, the food was on the shelf for pickup and seemed like it had been there for a while, as the food was ice cold when I got it home a couple minutes later. I recommend some sort of notification if food is ready to be picked up well before the estimated time. And if that’s not possible, have the food at least kept under heat and not out on a shelf near the front door. Willing to try them again sometime since the food didn’t taste bad. Just had to be reheated.
-
November 2023 by M
I come here every other weekend with my nephews for dinner. There are a ton of options! Their favorites are the spaghetti dinner and bacon, turkey sub. Mine is always a pizza and deep fried mushrooms! The food is SO good. The girls up front are always so nice! The food can sometimes take a bit longer at times but that’s to be expected on a Friday night at dinner time. Highly recommend! P.s. the Halloween decor was awesome! The nephews loved it!
-
November 2023 by matthew lyons
Came to Athens pizza for the 1st time tonight with my girlfriend, waited 1/2 an hour for 2 grinders & fries, 40 minutes goes by, they misplaced our order. Totally unacceptable, then they had to start over. My girlfriend is a diabetic & needed to have food, they only offered us a small bag of chips for waiting nearly an hour after we paid $30.00 for our food.We are still waiting, almost an hour later. We will never come here again.