-
January 2025 by Chris Joy Knight-Bennett
Pizza Mill is outstanding!! The owners are 1000% hands on, always go above and beyond and make amazing delicious, high quality food!!
-
December 2024 by Seth Schiele
Some of the best pizza I’ve ever had. Went there with the family and they all loved it. Highly recommend if you like pizza. Heck, I’d recommend even if you don’t.
-
October 2024 by Alexandra Mendez
It was disorganized.
-
October 2024 by Robyn C
Amazing pizza. Very fresh and homemade taste. Worth it!
-
October 2024 by kylie nelson
Cheesy bread 10/10
-
October 2024 by Jashan Lodha
Delicious food although very hot! Nice server although wait was very long and the atmosphere was fine but a bit drab, could use more decor. In total, it was a great little dinner meal, definitely worth it, especially so considering half the town is closed reducing one’s dinner options.
-
October 2024 by M. Kaase
This place was an unexpected experience. We didn't want the same old pizza, so we chose Pizza Mill from Google Maps suggestions. It's a small place, but we enjoyed the outside tables. When we received our pizza and cheese bread, we were just so happy with them. We had personal pan pizzas. We have never had a crispy crust pan pizza before. All the pan pizzas we have had were thick crust and greasy. These pans were crisp, seasoned nicely, and just wonderful tasting. The staff was just so helpful, kind, and respectful. If we ever visit Custer, SD again, we will be back. Thank you, Pizza Mill, for making pizza a nice experience!
-
October 2024 by Chuck Lunsford
Small, family owned pizza restaurant. The ingredients were very tasty, the crust was perfect. To be fair I am a sauce guy and there wasn't quite enough for my taste and it had a mild flavor.
-
October 2024 by Dianne White
What a terrific pizza restaurant. We had to come back for a second visit.
Dietary restrictions: Plus, the Gluten free was very good
-
October 2024 by Jeffrey Miller
Best pizza in the Black Hills!!
-
October 2024 by Deb Luecke Lessman
GREAT pizza! Great service! Wish I had come earlier to enjoy the outside seating.
-
September 2024 by Starr L.
Delicious pizza, great service, welcoming atmosphere! We enjoyed the pizza after riding the 1880 train.
-
September 2024 by Teresa Lucas
Could have used a little more sauce, but other that highly recommended. We got meat lover it was loaded..
-
September 2024 by Thomas White
The food was good, the restaurant was clean and attractive, and the staff was helpful. Pizza Mill provides good food at a reasonable price.
-
September 2024 by Christina
Nice restaurant, good service. Great food. Reasonable price.
