I've been a local for 23 years of my life, and man, have i been missing out! Tried it for the first time tonight. Great pizza and great prices! My only critique is i wish the bottom was a bit crispier. But honestly, one of the best ive had in the
November 2023
Hidden ? ? the lighting in the Parking lot could've been better. It was dark , it's already a place that's difficult to get to. The pizza is great though...not your ordinary
November 2023
Always love Penny's, we order often! Thanks for amazing food!
Locals nearly rioted when this pizza speakeasy shut down a few years ago, and then greeted its reopening like the Rapture. Penny’s keeps strange hours, so you’ll have to show up Thursday through Sunday for its thin, crisp pies with perfect, pocked and cornmeal-dusted crusts. And don’t expect anything fancy; this is just a couple kids and the ovens, delicious sweet-tart red sauce, and a white version with rich, creamy ricotta tucked beneath good mozzarella and sprinkled with salty, tasty sautèed garlic. Like all good speakeasies, you enter through a back door hidden from the street. Unlike most speakeasies, Penny’s has a sign. Originally established in 1970 and reopened in 2009.
