-
November 2023 by luv4phood
A few unique flavors were available including apple pie, espresso with toffee and banana pudding. The ice cream was good but could have been just a bit more creamy. The homemade waffle cones are delicious!
-
October 2023 by Donna Reeder
Too many ice crystals around the scoop bins so we decided to get a prepackaged individual serving ice cream instead.
-
March 2023 by RonnieG14
Their ice creams are delicious and they have a decent selection. I also get mine in a waffle cone and my wife gets hers in a cup. Prices have risen in the past couple of years, but what hasn't (Thanks Joe).
-
September 2022 by JaneOnAJourney
We had high hopes of a stellar homemade ice cream. Our ice cream had some banana flavor and was soooo yellow with dye that it was almost a neon yellow. I immediately grew suspiciousl of what other cheap, mundane chemical ingredients were being used. Will not be going back.
-
August 2022 by mucholdernow
This place was a go-to treat place for my family, grandkids, and guests. The ice cream is still good, but not as rich and delicious as it used to be. We have noticed that even the long lines to order have been shortened somewhat.
-
July 2022 by Trish L
I think about this ice cream for weeks after I go! The absolute best. My sons girlfriend said “a ten out of 10”. We had peach, strawberry cheesecake and coconut almond! Yummmmm! Chocolate Peanut Butter is my favorite. I can’t wait until next trip!!!
-
June 2022 by lovemydawgs
At the suggestion of a local gal, we took a little extra time to drive to this spot. Glad we did. It was a cute little place with a sweet courtyard to sit in. Ice cream choices were unique and were tasty. We loved sitting and enjoying. Parking area across the street was convenient.
-
March 2022 by iloveroyals
This ice cream was great - my husband and I had the cappuccino crunch and caramel cheesecake flavors. The staff was friendly and it was a fun stop. I’m giving 3 stars because it’s simply way overpriced. I get that this is a vacation spot but these were simple ice cream cones and it was $17 for the 2 of us. We both commented on how it wasn’t that much ice cream for the money.
-
September 2021 by mark a
I have a condo around the corner. This place is a mystery to me. We’ve had it when the kids were teens and just wanted to try and I guess feel like they need to have that experience. It’s junk ice cream. Anyone reviewing it higher than 2 stars is just caught up in a vacation moment. If it were in your hometown it would shut down in 3 months. Just get Publix green wise ice cream and eat it at your rental. You won’t waste your time in a line and it’s 100x better than this gelatin based ice cream. If you like generic ice cream, want to over pay and have major FOMO driven by BS social media, then go for it. If you need to get out, there’s far better ice cream up the road in gulf place per my college age kids.
-
September 2021 by Deborah B
This was our first stay at Blue Mountain beach, and we were able to walk to the Blue Mountain Creamery. This place was a HUGE hit with our family of 8, including the grandkids. Different flavors offered daily. Every night people were driving from Watercolor and Seaside to get ice cream here. There was always a line, but it was worth the wait!
-
June 2021 by R2259WFstans
We had heard so much about this place from friends and expected something a lot better. They had average flavors and the ice cream was nothing special. The nigh before we had stopped at Pecan Jacks about a mile from this place and the flavors and ice cream were so much better.
-
April 2021 by Leeroy145
Beware of inaccurate and inconsistent hours. I biked 6 miles each way with two 10 yo from Seagrove to Blue Mountain for what I was told was best ice cream in 30A. We will never know because they were not open at 10am as posted on their own website. Left my number with the one employee who arrived at 10:05 am. Was told that their manager Jed would call me back. It’s been over a week, still no response—-so a one star review it is. Also as others have said it is CASH ONLY and the ATM nearby was broken, so plan accordingly.
-
March 2021 by luckywahl
This little creamery was just a block away and we went multiple trips. Good ice cream with new flavors daily.
-
September 2020 by W9502ZZaliciab
After reading great reviews, we were excited to try the ice cream. We waited a long time while a grandmother and 2 kids debated over t-shirts. My husband and I both threw away our ice cream. The texture was no creamy at all. We went back for donuts a few days later. They were dry and lacked flavor. They went in the garbage can also.
-
August 2020 by OhioAmber
Delicious ice cream and waffle cones! Something for everyone. We visited in 2015 and returned again - seemed quite a bit busier! Cash payments only.