Sheetz of New Holland is a 24/7 convenience store and gas station providing kicked-up convenience. It offers award-winning Made-To-Order food, hand-made coffee drinks, and amazing milkshakes, including seasonal pumpkin flavors that do not disappoint. Customers can fuel up their car while choosing from a variety of packaged snacks, drinks, tobacco, CBD, and alcohol products. The location is known for being a really great place where service is pretty fast, and customers are often in and out quickly. The staff is generally friendly and helpful, with specific mention of a great cashier and a manager who puts customers first, though a rude employee is very rare. The facilities, including the bathrooms, are clean, and the pumps and soft drink machines work perfectly. The lot and gas pumps are typical, though one pump had an issue with bees during warm months. While most experiences are positive with no complaints, there was a noted incident regarding the alcohol sales policy that caused frustration. Overall, Sheetz has what you need, when you need it, and is accommodating for quick stops.
I love the New Sheetz. It looks like the Mennonite Mafia is checking up on things!
March 2025
It was closed for 3 months and after 2 days reopened... It looks like nothing changed. Pretty filthy and unkempt... But at least the parking lot is bigger now?
July 2024
This location is busy and does not meet the expectations for a Sheet’s. Often dirty and with loud music.
