-
March 2024 by Pete Sharp
This place is ok. It's not my favorite pizza, but they have some good deals sometimes. So I don't mind getting food there once in awhile. I always order online and pickup at the store.
-
January 2024 by Joey Ortiz
They got my order wrong and bye the time they came back with the pizza I ordered it was cold the manager wasn't rude but should have stepped up and comp that but instead I paid 37$ for a bland large pepperoni pizza and ten cold boneless wings.Ive had frozen pizza that's much
-
January 2024 by Bill Hapke
Good food and service.
-
December 2023 by Toni Coniglio
First time buying a Philly cheesesteak pizza, where is the sauce? , and it tasted like it had mayo on it! Did not like this pizza. Would not recommend!
-
December 2023 by June Szweda
I rarely write reviews but I thought it was necessary this time. I have ordered from this Papa John's location twice and both times the pizza was great. I have had Papa John's from many locations and it is not always good.Also, when I visited in person tonight the girl who waited on me was super friendly and even walked me to my car and opened the door for me. 5 stars
-
September 2023 by Francis gateru
Great pizza, great
-
August 2023 by Ann Marie
Great pizza ? service sometimes can be awful, but when they make a mistake, they will take care of you
-
July 2023 by Raju Acharya
Its too late always….Customer Service is very worstThey are Rude ?
-
May 2023 by R C.
Ordered from here the other day for delivery order was 45 dollars was so upset when I got my subs it was all bread with a spoonful of meat even-tipped driver 20 I eat from Parma's often in the York area and love their food but this was unacceptable
-
May 2023 by Jon Slaymaker
Normal , good pizza - not raving over it not downing it . Just mid class
-
January 2023 by Adrienne Trout Fellenbaum
Very good stugg crust
-
December 2022 by Bill R.
No pepperoni. And not NY pie !!Horrible crap. Never buy again!! As far as I'm concerned, they stole $43 from me.
-
October 2022 by Um, “TheOtherOne”
Meh, it's okay. AMIRIGHT, they came out with a new pizza called the New Yorker. I know, it's not new, but apparently Papa John's thinks it is. The app told me my pizza was ready for pickup but stood there for 10 minutes before it was ready. I know, Karen, 10 minutes is not a big deal in life, just a little annoying. Got home and the pizza was just barely done.Want a really good pizza? Stop at Two Cousins literally just two doors east of this joint on Columbia Avenue. They've got some great pizzas...wings too...with bones in them...not chunks of frozen, breaded, pressed chicken parts.
-
September 2022 by Todd Monyer
First I ordered my pizza online. It told me it would be delivered in 35-45 minutes. After an hour and 20 minutes I tried to call to check on my order. NO ONE answered the phone. It rang about 20 xs & it was never answered. My wife then tried to call & again, no one ever picked up the phone. I guess if you don't order it online then you're not ordering from Papa John's because they never answer the phone!
-
August 2022 by Justin
This is more for papa johns corporate but I ordered delivery before I placed my order there was no estimate given as soon as I placed it the estimate time was 2 hours I think it’s ridiculous you don’t get a estimate before you place your order.
