-
March 2024 by Manh Cuong Phi
DO NOT SELL YOUR HIGH GRADE RARE COINs here. I recently went in to sell some peace and morgan dollars. The first batch I gave them a mixed of VG, XF dollars, the guy took a while to look and came back with same price for similar VG and XF same year, mint dollar lol. We agreed on the price, and I thought maybe since they are low grade so they don't care, so I send 2nd batches of previously certified MS/PL65-66 coins without holder to test their price and guess what they came back with XF+ condition and try to convince me sell them. What a complete JOKE. I guarantee those coins are even better than their MS-63,64 at the shops, it is night and day difference, even a kid can tell. I wasn't pleased and took back all MS coins, also took back XF stuff, only sell VG ones since there are no price difference between VG-XF anyway. The guy noticed and immediately changed this attitude, lure me into trade and showing no interest in buying low grade dollars. BIG BIG red flags!!! The coin shop looks nice and professional, but don't be fool they are there to take advantage of new collectors and make good profits. DO NOT TRUST THEM ON OLD GEM RARE COINS. Either send them for certification or go for an experience numismatist.UPDATE: Google review won't let me reply so I am gonna update the review according to shop reply. 2 of 5 of Morgans were certified PL but he didn't "feel" or sure they were. Assuming that what he believe is true at MS63 San Francisco that he offer 40$. Yes 40$ for MS63+ S Morgan when ebay and other coin shops sell them for at least 115,120$ at MS 61, 250$ at MS63+, you heard him. I also offer them 2 key date BU peace dollar, he came back with 450$ for both. I went to another store later, got a 900$ offer, still not even selling them yet. Do price researches on your coins. STAY AWAY !!!!
-
February 2024 by King DP
Awesome place. Bought my first gold coin from them today. I had a million questions, and they answered every one of them with kindness & honesty. I greatly appreciate you guys!
-
January 2024 by Paula Froke
These folks are fantastic -- thoroughly knowledgeable and professional, while also extremely compassionate and personable. The compassion part of the equation meant a whole lot as I was dealing with relics gathered over time by my grandparents and father, and painstakingly assembled by my dad. I worked mainly with Lillian, whose particular acts of grace literally made me cry (good tears!) The fact that it's a family business dating back nearly a century is so special as well.
-
December 2023 by Mike Gecht (SanibelMike)
After passing Edleman's for many decades, I decideded to visit them and ask for help in understanding the value in my late father-in-law's coin collection. Liam explained the process as he evaluated the collection thoroughly. He was very forthright in the value and substantuatetions.Given my trust in Liam and Edleman's, I would not hesitate returning to their store as well as sharing my visit with my friends, etc.
-
December 2023 by N N
Honest shop.Quickly sold a gold coin there for a price that was fair for both of us.I highly recommend this place and i will be a returning customer for sure!
-
September 2023 by Kyle Speirs
The gentleman we dealt with was professional and friendly. He took his time with us and reviewed every coin and provided a back history of every currency. Highly recommended!
-
July 2023 by Oscar Cleaver
I just wanted to say that the two guys I’ve talked to on multiple visits were super helpful and nice. They have a great inventory and offer the most $ for gold and silver that I’ve seen anywhere. They’re my go to spot for selling despite being a pretty far hike for me. ???
-
May 2023 by Drew Conway
Have done many many deals with Andrew and team. Wonderful experience every single time!
-
March 2023 by Mike C
Always friendly and fair. Great prices. Good stock and variety. Clean, safe store and location. Open on Saturdays.
-
February 2023 by Thomas Homza
Good afternoon, I visited this store and was blown away by how professional and knowledgeable the young men working there are. I purchased 17 Silver Eagles and got a great deal. I also bought a Reverse proof 2021 set at a decent price.. They have quality and quantity in this store. You will be pleased if you do business with them. I will be happy to come back and purchase more because the prices are fair and reasonable. If you're looking for Gold and Silver along with collectable items you can rest assured they probably have it. Great business.
-
February 2023 by Jon Hamill
Easy to do business with. I sold a coin I got from the US mint at a good price to them.
-
December 2022 by Sheila Wisniewski
Worth the drive! My first visit to this location and I’m very impressed. The store was clean and well organized, Andrew was a pleasure to work with. He was very friendly and professional and immediately put me at ease. I will be doing more business with this store. Highly recommend them.
-
November 2022 by Sam Nemirovsky
Endrew, is extremely professional and will always go out of his way to help. Always provides a very aggressive price for my coins. Great staff. Someone you can trust!!
-
October 2022 by Ryan Vanderhoff
I've bought and sold several times at Edelman's Coins and have always received excellent value and customer service.
-
September 2022 by Scott Schultz
I left a one-star review quite a few years ago. I was upset about customer service and I the prices they were offering me. Well they changed it around they are very friendly and welcoming and their prices are on par or better than most other coin shops. And they do have a very large selection of really nice coins, especially older silver coins late 1790s thru1800s. Fair prices and very knowledgeable. My first visit must have been an off day for them, it happens.
