-
March 2024 by Robert Ebersole
Sat in my car with my kid and shared a pizza. I don't think I've ever had it that fresh. Very good.
-
February 2024 by Helen lyons
Always on time every time, great workers at this location ?Wheelchair accessibility: Doors open up wide enough for wheelchair
-
December 2023 by David
Love the bone-in parmesan baked
-
November 2023 by Cee MacDee
Our first time at this location was great. Looking forward to our next visit.
-
November 2023 by Tom D.
It seems rather odd for me to be rating a chain restaurant so highly, but honestly, they deserve it at this location. I've eaten food from Papa John's locations in multiple cities across the country, and this one by far exceeded my expectations based on how the other locations were. I actually enjoy the food from here and it's always made to exact specifications. Even when we order delivery, it is always prompt and on time within their estimates. I have to say, for a national chain, this particular location has me really impressed. I wish their other locations were this good!
-
October 2023 by S C
Look....its Papa Roach.....lol - talking with the cashier they are fighting over parking spaces with the business next to them. This is a good example of poor cybersecurity either configuration or practice....too funny!
-
October 2023 by Cy Spencer
Staff is very friendly!! And pizza is on point!! 5/5
-
September 2023 by Rob Reznikov
Way overpriced, for the pizza that you get its not even that good. The people who take the orders are very rude, definitely would not recommend this Papa John's, especially when I saw a cockroach, in one of the reviews. Yuck
-
September 2023 by Dee Simmons
I am usually very happy with my order but this week I ordered the BBQ chicken bacon papadia and the works pizza and other stuff. My papadia had no BBQ sauce or bacon on it at all. Just chicken and cheese. Luckily I got some bbq dipping sauce and could add that to it. The pizza only had toppings in the center of the pizza. They literally looked like they were just dumped in the center before cooking. I know places get busy but the employees need to slow down enough to make the items correctly. I am not looking for anything but just wanted to make management aware of this for future orders. We all have a bad day now and then. As I said before I am usually very happy with my orders. Thank you
-
August 2023 by Leahm Grove
Extremely rude young people who have ZERO respect for the other business in the complex. I was parked in by a delivery truck while visiting another shop in the complex. When I asked them to have the truck moved I was treated with extreme disrespect. On top of that, the shop was filthy, including several dead cockroaches visible. THANKFULLY I did not get food from them.
-
July 2023 by Linda Stahl
Pizza was great, but there needs to be a Papa Johns to be located in New Oxford PA. There isn't many food places in this area!
-
July 2023 by Amber Byron
Same mistake was made more than once even after bringing it to their attention for this specific order. They wanted to issue me a credit when I won’t use since now on I’ll be supporting local rather than chain so asked for my delivery fee to be returned at least since now the food we DID have would be cold and I had to run to the store myself after paying delivery fee and tipping. I Was told they couldn’t do that and wouldn’t send someone else out.
-
July 2023 by Cal Shaffer
I went there to get a pizza and out from my box crawled a roach!! And while I was waiting I went nextdoor and when I came back they were trying to tow my car! I can't give negative stars or I
-
July 2023 by Frank Pellegrino
Delivery is always super fast. Food comes hot and accurate.
-
May 2023 by A&M asmr
I got pizza from this place one time it delivered and I ate it and then after that I felt completely sick I was sick for a whole week throwing up and my stomach pain was unbearable I will never order from this place again I do not recommend
