Casey's is known for its delicious pizza, which comes at a decent price and offers plenty of vegetarian toppings. Customers appreciate the friendly staff, with one reviewer noting the kindness of an employee who delivered pizzas to a car. The store is clean and convenient, although some mention that food prices can be a bit high and the taste sometimes resembles generic frozen options. Casey's is family-friendly, often busy with kids, and provides adequate parking, including handicap accessibility. However, it's important to note that the Jay store does not open at 4 AM, and their gas pumps are not available 24 hours.
