Casey's in El Reno is a popular gas station known for its friendly staff and clean facilities. The pizza is widely praised as being "so flippin' good," though some customers have experienced issues with customization orders. While the kitchen staff can sometimes seem overwhelmed, especially during busy hours, the front-of-house employees are consistently described as helpful and pleasant. The bathrooms, in particular, are well-maintained, with a customer service representative named Tyler keeping the men's restroom "immaculate" at night. Despite a few isolated incidents of long wait times or order mix-ups, the overall consensus is that Casey's is a great gas station with a good food selection, including no-ethanol fuel options. While the business may be short-staffed at times, the general experience is positive, with customers praising the clean store and friendly atmosphere.
Forgot extra sauces that were paid for along with a topping on one of the pizzas
July 2025
Christian, above and beyond service. Very respectful. It's hard to find this caliber of customer service these days. Truly an asset to Casey's
May 2024
One of the best gas stations in El Reno. The staff is really nice and helpful in the bathrooms. Stay pretty clean. There is a customer service representative named Tyler who keeps the men's bathrooms at night immaculate. 5 out 5.
