Acme Fresh Market is described by some as a hidden gem and a clean store with great buys, especially on weekly deals. Customers note a large and nice selection of most everything, including cheeses in the deli and well-stocked seafood and produce sections. However, several reviews mention that prices are generally high unless items are on sale. Some find the store quiet and not very busy, while others feel it can seem deserted. Feedback on promotions is mixed, with some customers frustrated that deals require buying multiple items. Management and policy changes have also been a point of criticism for some long-time shoppers.