-
January 2024 by harry
Super Rad! Pretty neat selection. I'd say 60/40 casual wear (hoodies, t-shirts)/"dressed up" gothic (dresses, corsets, blouses). I was pleasantly surprised with their sizes as I'm mid-size (18 pants, XXL/XXXL shirts + dresses) and they had a lot of stuff in my size!For larger sizes the selection seemed okay, I believe they mentioned expecting more plus size corsets in the coming months.Personally I believe that nothing was too expensive, definitely cheaper than places like hot topic, torrid, killstar, etc. which is relieving to see.The only negatives I'd say were that there weren't as much dress-ier/romantic options as I would have liked, but for some quick, everyday staples it's great.Also for those w/ sensory sensitivities there is an incense-y smell here as well as the sister store. I actually really like the smell of incense, but it may bother those who don't.However the reason I rated 5 stars:1. ACCESSORIES GALORE. Super cute jewelry, bags, harnesses, etc.2. Super friendly staff! I have pretty bad social anxiety and they were so chill and helpful. It was my first time purchasing a corset and they talked me through it, reassured me, and just generally made me feel a lot more comfortable. As someone who is midsize shopping for something like a corset can be kind of scary, but I sensed no judgement AT ALL. For example, I love corsets style-wise but didn't really want too much cinching. The staff checked with my comfort level multiple times AND super casually got me a larger size. I usually dread trying stuff on because of that reason, but they were so nice and encouraging!!Overall: reasonably priced, mostly casual gothic/witchy items, really cute stuff, great service. I am defo planning on returning :)
-
December 2023 by dripping from the ceiling
A lot to be desired.On a positive note, they do feature genuine plus size clothing. Not a lot of alternative/goth stores can say that. They feature a wide array of pleasant deals, even if they don't have a bunch of plus size clothing for plus size individuals to choose from. They have nice variety of different items, though a lot of it is expensive.This shop was originally marketed as a more inclusive and cheaper hot topic. It's not.I'll be honest, this store might've been worth the 2+ hour drive that my mother and I drove to get here the first time, but it was not worth the 2nd visit.A lot of the clothing was from SHEIN, something that discouraged me from buying the first time I was here - I asked about it, they told me that they didn't know any better. It seemed like all the plus size clothing they had was from SHEIN. They told me they were just getting rid of stock. I accepted their reasoning and purchased, assuming it to have just been a genuine mistake on their part. When I went back in yesterday, I saw even more SHEIN clothing. I did a little bit of research and found out that they've been operating for years. Plenty of time to educate themselves on SHEIN. If I wanted a cheap, low quality top from SHEIN - I'd buy from SHIEN. Not them, for an even more expensive price.My mother was particularly excited to go back to the sister store that features metaphysical items, but she was disappointed. I didn't understand why she didn't buy anything until we left and she told me. She told me that all the stuff was just commercial, it had no life or substance or story to it. For reference, we have a wonderful indigenous tribal shop near us. Lovely native amercian woman who runs it, she always is sourcing things as local as she can and supporting her community. She commonly sells jewelry and art made by *her* community, she gives *her* community a space in their shop. It all can be sourced down to where it came from.Perhaps, the bitterest taste of the entire experience was being told that some things were made for "skinny girls" - and that's not inference, or me taking something the wrong way, the lady at the front desk told me that. Like she was grossed out I even suggested I try it on. It hurt.If you're looking for a genuine plus size store, this isn't it. I'd recommend Torrid, honestly. They have good deals for clearance and have amazing sizes for ALL bodies, not just those who are skinny.I'm sorry, but this store is fake.It was fun to go to one time, but it isn't worth the hassle to go back. I don't know if I'll be getting a reply to this review trying to explain their side of things, but please don't bother. Genuinely, this store wounded me. A lot of talk of inclusiveness for it to simply just be cheap Amazon trickents and SHEIN clothing.
-
November 2023 by Stephen Peacock
If you are looking for a store that has unique clothing and accessories then this is it. They have a great selection. Every time I visit they have new items available and great prices. Clothes fit and feel great. Always felt welcomed by the amazing staff. Definitely will keep shopping here.
-
October 2023 by Bex Juhasz
I saw this place on tiktok and was extremely excited for the plus sized options, which they did have, not many, but they did.Every clothing item that I touched, t shirts dresses, sweaters, each one felt super scratchy and very unfortable. I loved the designs, though. They were really cool and well done.When I went into the store with my partner, we both got headaches from the smell. It was intense. Candles and all. We had to leave because we couldn't handle it. We did get a free gift because we bought two t shirts that were 80 dollars..... a patch.The ladies were super nice, good customer service.Uncomfortable clothes, headache store, a lot of good designs and products, and great customer service.I will sadly not be going back.
-
October 2023 by Mike Rickman
Recently stopped again at The Posh Pagan in historic Hamilton Ohio and once more found some really cool clothing for guys so I got a couple shirts and a pair of shorts. Very comfortable and definitely stylish for sure. I should have asked what scent of incense they had burning so I could have gotten some. I was there one time they had a weird odor that was coming from the Asian Fish store next door, but that store has since closed yay! Yet another awesome experience at Posh Pagan. Thats for all the help from your most friendly staff! See you again soon!
-
August 2023 by Monica Gundrum
LOVE THIS PLACE!!! My husband and myself came in on a couples weekend yesterday while driving to KY and loved the custom attention from the ladies working there and the free makeup bag and extra pen charms was extra special to me THANKS. I don't talk to people and they talked with hubbie while I was allowed to dig through the endless basket of pen charms to add to my beautiful crochet witches hat THAT I ALSO FOUND THERE...LOL I follow them on FB and TikTok and was shy to say hello. I Did NOT see the shirt I was kinda looking for. Soo I'll just order on line. But did fine a tapestry for my She-shed and acid drip style Alice in Wonderland purse and hubbie found a shower curtain with a Reaper and cut off shirt that has a gorgeous grim reaper on the back. We will be back another day when I am more in tune with my inner goddess.
-
August 2023 by Faith Garcia
Absolutely love this place! Love the size selection on most clothing. My fellow luscious witches and goths must visit! The staff is so friendly! And just a few doors down -The Alternative Path: Coexist! I'm in need of another visit to both places!
-
August 2023 by Nancy Spencer
Loved it. Lots of unique clothing and accessories. Found some great deals. Highly recommend. Drove over two hours to get there and plan to do it again someday.
-
August 2023 by Emily Kerchenfaut
They’re so friendly here!! Love it, drove 2 hours to come shop here and was made to feel so welcomed!!They gave us a free bracelet as a welcome gift love yall
-
August 2023 by Danielle Hibbs
My kids and I traveled about an hour to see this place and we were not disappointed. We also visited their sister store, The Alternative Path-Coexist, and were equally impressed by it. The employees were so nice and personable. We enjoyed our chat and exploring. Such a great gem in Hamilton! We hope to be back soon to get Ren gear.
-
August 2023 by Alexia long
The most amazing energy as soon you walk through the door, had a great conversation with one of the wonderful ladies that were there. Their clothing material feels so soft and they have a wide selection of sizes. I just wish they were closer to my hometown so i could visit more often lol. Definitely worth the detour on our road trip.
-
August 2023 by Chickadee Chick
This store looks so cool! Didn’t get to go but the online impression looks amazing. I love to support local businesses and I have been told they will ship to me. Awesome selection of witchy things.
-
July 2023 by Ariel Deaton
Had an absolutely wonderful experience here! An amazing selection of clothing and other items! the owner was so kind and helpful, definitely will be going back!
-
May 2023 by Ta'lena Wilson
I’ve been wanting to go for a while and I’m so happy I finally decided on the drive. They have super cute options, it’s really nice having a physical store I can shop at. Clothes always fit my body differently I like being able to try on things and see my options. Super sweet, social, very helpful. I will definitely be coming back to splurge when I can.
-
May 2023 by Chelsea H.
Hello, I just stopped into your store today on my lunch break from work with my daughter and shortly after we went into both stores. No one said anything to her as we were looking around, in fact an employee congratulated her on her pregnancy as they left the store. We also went into Subway and had a nice lunch. I left to go to work and my daughter calls me stating that she was stopped outside and got banned from both stores for shop lifting and that she is no longer welcome and that you have camera proof. Didn't show her the proof and when I called to speak to someone at the store about it I was told they are not in the store. Because she loves both the stores so much she has spent a lot of her money in your store so this must be a mistake. She has been away for 4 months and just came back. Thank you and have a great day. So I am leaving a negative review because of this encounter. Thank you and have a great day