Auto Repair in Bucyrus, OH

14 locations found near Bucyrus

“I think these are the people that used to be next to the skate ring seem to be very friendly and parts are priced below competition. So I had them order me a heater core for my car and it didn't fit...even though I already opened it and tried to use it they returned it. This happened on Christmas eve, anyways John I'm assuming and his daughter still tried to help me figure out what to do since the part wouldn't work knowing they were not gonna make a sale at this time all I'm saying is I'm grateful for polite people. So often people are just out to make a buck I didn't feel that way at all from these guys. Thanks again for your help. By the way I figured the issue out that manufacturer just sent the wrong part got a new one and it fit.”

4.9 Superb48 Reviews

“Had an issue with a tire on the way to the campground on 7-19-2025. Found this place on google and we only had 30 minutes til they closed. We went there and the guy called a parts store and he got what we needed and had us back on the road in 30 minutes. Thanks again for saving the day!! Thanks for staying over on a Saturday.”

4.8 Superb81 Reviews

“★★★★★

Since moving back to Bucyrus, I've been on the lookout for a trustworthy mechanic, and I found exactly what I was looking for at Hometown Garage. As a woman, I've unfortunately had experiences at other places where I was upcharged and condescended to. It's so refreshing to be treated with respect and not taken advantage of at Hometown Garage.

The team here not only does a fantastic job with repairs, but they also take the time to explain what needs to be done and why. I left feeling educated and confident about the work performed on my car. Their customer service is top-notch, and their prices are very reasonable. It's clear they value their customers and their reputation.

Hometown Garage has definitely earned my business again and again. If you're looking for an honest, respectful mechanic who provides excellent service at a great price, this is the place to go!”

5 Superb29 Reviews

“Ive been using Randy's since I moved to Bucyrus, for various vehicles. Although they're always busy, Greg does his best for fit me into the schedule as soon as possible. You won't get ripped off here, and you can trust what they tell you! Extremely fair prices 5/5 recommend”

4.7 Superb81 Reviews

“It was a very good experience. They made it easy to schedule, I asked for an estimate beforehand and they gave it promptly. My total matched the estimate, no added fees which was awesome. They were on time and had it done quickly. The people were very nice. He went above and added washer fluid which I really appreciate. Definitely recommend.”

4.7 Superb58 Reviews

“I made a reasonable offer over the phone. They called me back and told me that would work. Came in and picked up the car same day after work. Working with John was easy and straightforward, they don’t use high pressure tactics to rip you off like many dealerships. Just make a reasonable offer for what it’s worth.”

5 Superb22 Reviews

“Matt was very friendly & honest. They were able to get me in the shop in 2 days & fixed the same day. Price is reasonable too! It is comforting knowing I have a great mechanic/shop close to home if I ever have any issues!”

4.6 Superb60 Reviews

“They are the only 2 guys that will touch my truck. Had a blow out on a clamp and they fixed it great. Now here for a full custom 3inch true dual set up and amazing work again! Thanks guys”

4.7 Superb52 Reviews

“I was in need of a set of Mastercraft 10 ply tires I'm from out of state so I had my wife call around, so that the attendante wouldn't see our plates, and everybody was within $75 on a set. Something about this shop caught My wife's attention so she ordered the tires had an appointment 2 Days Later. They got the truck in on time did a thorough check on all of our fluids my wife asked him to check out the front end and there wasn't anything wrong with it, and they didn't try to sell her anything that she didn't need. They're very courteous down to earth and treated you like you were a neighbor. These people have been in business for a long time and there's a reason for that I would highly recommend this shop to anybody that needs tires. Thank you for treating my wife well. A lot of automotive service centers treat women like they're stupid this is not one of those places”

4.7 Superb22 Reviews

“Highly recommend! They are quick and extremely affordable! I always buy my tires from them... they're the cheapest in town! And the owner truly cares about his customers!”

4.6 Superb20 Reviews

“Absolutely one of the best places around, with something you just don’t find everywhere - ethics. Harold will treat you like family and make sure the problem is fixed. Nothing more, nothing less. He charges a more than reasonable price for the quality of service he provides. Without hesitation, I would recommend you bring your cars here. We will.Service: Brakes”

5 Superb9 Reviews

“River helped me get the car I wanted, and went above and beyond to make him self available on my schedule. Great customer service and lots of friendly faces they also have some bad ass cars.”

4.1 Good154 Reviews

Related topics