-
April 2024 by Jae Rustan
smells like sewage, saw a roach, but good quality ice cream. chocolate sprinkles are the best thing on the menu. can’t get much with 5 bucks now, definitely can’t get anything for $1, inflation and corporate greed made prices skyrocket. would rather go to a different location :)
-
March 2024 by R I
Great milkshakes and floats.
-
March 2024 by Josh Lefan
We are from Nashville, Tennessee and went into Graeter’s for the first time ever. Andrew was the most awesome human being I’ve probably ever met in my life. His constant smile and knowledge of different combinations of ice cream blew me away. He introduced me to a new way of peanut butter and chocolate. He was kind enough to warm both of them up and fold them in together on top of each other. Then he placed it atop some of the most beautiful creamery deliciousness I’ve ever experienced. God bless this man.
-
March 2024 by SheIs TheHustle
The staff working tonight was lovely. You had a manager, a young man, and another female employee. The team work they out in was great. They each stepped in to provide a service to an individual group and worked the line down. I say the atmosphere is a two due to the weird smell that gives off a plumbing issue that seems to be ongoing. Last year when we came the smell was there. It’s only near the back door by the bathroom. Nowhere near the ice cream/food products. Keep up the great work because this team works well together. My lil one seen them working through their shift with such ease and politeness that she decided this would be her first job because they make it seem like a good place.
-
February 2024 by crystin Turner
The place smelled of raw sewage and mold I walked out as soon as I walked in. Very dissapointed almost ruined my taste for icecream that was
-
February 2024 by Kevin Microsoft
I don't like ice cream myself. My wife wanted to go, so I slugged through it.Dietary restrictions: If you are intolerant two people or dairy, do not come here expecting an enjoyable time.
-
February 2024 by Javier Canales
The ice cream was good but the place smelled weird like
-
February 2024 by Eden Gutai
bad smell.. couldn’t even stand to be in the building. i’ve been here once before and the ice cream was good. but I can’t come back here because the smell & ambience is horrible. jeni’s or udf >
-
February 2024 by Aero
Hmm interesting enough this place has made me gag and also like their ice cream. There seems to be a very weird smell as soon as you walk in. Kinda like your grandpas old clothes and dirty mop water. This is on several occasions of me visiting. So it seems to be either not acknowledged or an invisible force is altering peoples sense of smell. The staff is very friendly which makes up for your time wondering what that smell is. The ice cream is okay and locals seem to enjoy it.
-
January 2024 by Nick Waldo
Arguably the best ice cream in Columbus. A special flavor of ice cream every month. Plus all the classics. Staff is friendly and will get you through the line quickly. The building is a bit old and has an older building smell to it. I don’t think they can help it, but don’t let that take away from the great ice cream they serve.
-
January 2024 by Christina Chandler
I always enjoy this location.
-
October 2023 by Kyaira Stewart
Very friendly staff. Super quick getting to our orders and so many choices to choose from. I got a double scoop of salted caramel chip and chocolate chip cookie dough and my bf got a triple scoop of double cookies and cream and chocolate chip cookie dough.Parking was limited and coming through the back door you are overwhelmed with the smell of the bathroom but the ice cream was definitely refreshing and needed on such a nice day.
-
October 2023 by Amber J
SUCH delicious ice cream!! I had the s’mores and pumpkin flavor- I’m allergic to gluten, so it was amazing to have gluten free s’mores ice cream.
-
September 2023 by Ingrid Weland
Friendly staff, old fashioned ice cream store with both indoor and outdoor seating. I got the salted caramel chip and it was yummy. Johnson’s is just down the road and $1 less for the same serving size. Both are good; Graeter’s has a lot more branding merchandise.
-
September 2023 by Julia B.
The ice cream is delicious. Thankfully they have an outside patio because the inside smells foul like wet dog or wet cat urine.