Amazing first experience the owner Lou is an absolute sweetheart and knows his stuff! The meat is top quality and fresh and the store is super clean. Prices are reasonable and worth it for the quality of meat and service you get. I’m a customer for life now and will not go anywhere else. Best butcher on Long Island hands... read full comment
October 2024
The feta/spinach and cheddar/broccoli chicken burgers were outstanding as were the turkey burgers. The freshness stands out with minimal seasoning. Lou is an outstanding guy to deal with. The BBQ is great too along with the sides. Yours truly, The Big fan.
October 2024
First time here and can't wait to come back. Wonderful staff, great meat and fabulous experience.
Prime Time Butcher is family-owned and operated local business in Woodbury, New York. For over thirty years we continue to meet the culinary needs of caring cooks and food lovers. We are one of the few exclusive purveyors of the nation's most-coveted Dry Aged Prime Beef. Complementing our exceptional meat selection are American Lamb; All Natural Poultry, Beef and Pork. Our products are hand-selected from the finest Prime USDA suppliers. We hand-cut every item the old-fashioned way. Trimmed and wrapped to your specifications, each order includes expert cooking instructions to ensure superb results. Our kitchens are brimming with a wonderful array of cooked foods…from our very best classic recipes to season fresh starters, main and sides.
Other Information
Parking: Street, Lot, Private
Specialties: Company Events, American Restaurant, Business Events, American, American Food, Celebrations, Executive Events
