24HR Fuel Available Crosby’s is your local family-owned convenience store and gas station, proudly serving communities across NY & PA. Offering oven-fresh pizza slices, quality fuel, and more— Crosby’s has everything you need! Stop in store now or order online!
Guess I should have read the reviews first. Ordered a pizza and was told 30 mins. Arrived in about 30 give or take and it’s going to be another 20. Also no restrooms while I now have to wait. They sent me to Tim Hortons
February 2026
Ciera needs to be fired she’s so lazy she never makes buffalo chicken pizza during lunch rush 12pm-1pm second day wasted time on lunch break
December 2025
This place is horrible workers are rude depending on who’s you get and never seem to want to work the only reason I give 4 stars is because of the pizza and som really good workers
