-
March 2024 by Heather Htun
We were touring chocolate places on the North Fork yesterday for an event that we are hosting. Nancy was amazing and the only owner/manager to really take her time speaking with us to see our vision for the event! She is so kind and sweet and full of ideas for us to use for our event! She took her time, even when she was about to close, to speak with us and really let us know what we should be looking at price wise and what would work best with what we were serving and using the chocolate for. Definitely off the beaten track and a little farther outside of town, but truly worth the extra 5 minutes to drive! Nancy really cares about people and brings out true enthusiasm when she speaks about her chocolates and all that she can do with them!
Parking: The lot is shared with other businesses, but is huge!
Kid-friendliness: Her store is fun and exciting! I didn't have my kids with me, but I can really see them enjoying themselves in her store! She mixes vintage decorations with her vibrantly decorated sweets to make you feel warm and instantly happy when walking into her establishment.
-
January 2023 by Sebast
Super sweet proprietor, excellent tasting chocolate. Best dark chocolate peanut cluster I ever ate! Thank you
-
September 2022 by Chris Kies
She makes all her own chocolate. It is noticeable too. We are definitely going back. Infact...kinda hard to stay away. It was that good.A native NOFO.
-
June 2021 by Kyle Schwartz
Great personable service and great chocolate
-
January 2021 by Fred West
Chocolate taste unbelievable service is great
-
February 2020 by Jeanine Born
Delicious candy and warm inviting atmosphere. The owner is extremely kind and always a pleasure to be around.
-
March 2018 by Frank T.
I believe the name of the shop is currently North Fork Girl Sweet Shop. I just know it as the red building across the street from 7-11 and Blue Duck. I have been going here for years especially before Holidays. The shop is small but it's loaded with seasonal and everyday chocolates and candies. The owner, I think her name is Nancy will offer you samples. Prices are reasonable for homemade chocolates and the North Fork.
-
June 2015 by Kyle C.
This place is a tradition for our family. Every time we are out here on the weekends, we always make our way to the shop's owner Nancy, or the "Candy Lady," as we call her. The shop is tiny but so charming, packed with SO MUCH CANDY. Total candy wonderland, not to mention other goodies like jams, sauces, spices, candles, nic nacs and decor. Nancy is as sweet as her candy, always giving us a free sample of her delicious homemade chocolate whenever we come in. My personal favorite are her coconut delights (creamy coconut center covered in milk chocolate). I can eat an entire box of those. Her nut and caramel turtles are also to die for!!! The hospitality in this little shop is what makes places like Southold and the North Fork in general so special. Everyone takes pride in their crafts and make their customers happy and loyal. I'm so happy to support Nancy and her wonderful little business making delicious chocolates. If you're ever in Southold and have a sweet tooth, be sure to stop by and get your fix!
-
October 2014 by Megan C.
I can't believe no other fellow Yelpers have reviewed this sweet spot (no pun intended) yet! After a not-so-awesome visit to Blue Duck Bakery across the street, our need for fresh fudge and homemade confectionery items was still nagging. We crossed the street and entered the charming little cottage that was literally filled to the rim with candies, chocolates, seasonal wares, and staffed by a very sweet lady who owns the shop and makes most of the edibles herself. It was obvious that the shopkeeper/candy maker was very passionate about what she does, as she proudly offered us countless LARGE samples of her homemade fresh fudge, chocolate covered pretzels, truffles, etc. She makes almost everything in house, and also peddles mass-produced candies that she packages up herself into cute little gift packs, or in this case, fall-themed and Halloween-themed sets. So cute! Her prices were not at all extravagant, and she accepted all major credit cards. Watch the shop hours, as she's not open 7 days a week; it's understandable that this one-woman operation needs some time off to keep up with the demand for her candies and chocolates! We left with bags full of goods: milk- and dark chocolate-covered caramels (homemade caramel for sure), dark chocolate and sprinkle-covered giant pretzels, milk chocolate-covered "turtles", dark chocolate-covered coconut with almond, "Snickers" fudge, peanut butter fudge, pumpkin fudge, and one of her pre-packaged Halloween-themed gift baskets. You can also find cute locally-themed items for purchase to supplement/offset your sugary purchases!
-
February 2011 by Dawn Powers
Chocolate Cashew Turtles....YUM!
