Toy Stores near Southampton, NY

“Stevenson’s Toys is a shining example of why we all should support small businesses. They saved my son’s fifth birthday by going above and beyond to help me out after I had unbelievably bad luck finding the Playmobil house that he wanted and is near impossible to find. The first one I ordered from another seller was stolen from my front porch, and the second from a different seller was inexplicably canceled by the seller en route to my house. Enter Stevenson’s Toys, which is literally on the other side of the country. They had a single one in stock and after I explained my plight to Rosie, she not only provided a photo of the toy but her number to reach out with any questions. The owner himself called me a short while later to confirming shipping costs with UPS. When I didn’t receive a tracking number I reached out and they got it to me right away. And after two failed attempts, it arrived on my doorstep a day early! Both Rosie and Roy were incredibly kind and helpful and wonderful examples of what customer service should be. Although we are in Colorado, you better believe that I will continue shopping here not only for my son, but for my nephew who is local to the area. If you have the opportunity to shop here, do it. I’m sure you won’t be disappointed.”

“Every year without fail this is my first spot to stop! The chocolates are to die for, and the unique gifts are just fabulous! Everything you could possibly need from toys to accessories to gorgeous clothes, whether it's Christmas or 4th of July! The staff, and the owners are the nicest people I've ever met. They treat you like family!”

“Tried and true, not much has changed here in the 25 years of my stopping in. They've got a wide selection of pretty much everything you could need. Lots of vintage toys, puzzles, cool crafts, and the type of toys kids these days don't know exist.I had to buy a store t-shirt! They're simple and not in-your-face.”

“A trip to sag harbor isn't complete without shopping at the kite store. Fun for kids and adults! Fidgets, toys,gags, trends, candy, and of course kites! Each time I visit they have something new. Never gets boring. But the real stars are the staff. Everyone is warm, welcoming, and helpful. A true gem.”

“This place is great. It’s been a while since I’ve been but have fond memories of. Growing up my family and I spent our summers in Noyac and visited the Wharf Shop quite often. Great customer service and beautiful products. In fact I still have a seagull bracelet that my Mom bought for me over 50 years ago! If you’re in Sag Harbor definitely make sure to stop in. You won’t be disappointed.”