-
September 2024 by J M
Went out of my way to drive all the way from sag harbor to go to peconix prime meats and they wouldn’t cut me the steaks I asked for even though there were multiple large pieces in the display and told me to come back in an hour or so even though there was only one other customer in the shop. Terrible customer service! I’ve recommended prime meats to so many people over the years that is going to end. Can’t believe I wasted so much of my time trying to support this business.
-
October 2023 by Michelle Fernandez
The only bad thing about this place is we don't live closer to you! My husband has been coming here from Huntington to purchase our steaks, sausages, meatloaf and now I try the twice baked potatoes. I'm done, always amazing, always friendly, never disappoints. This is the spot. Thank you!
-
September 2023 by Anne Sullivan
Peconic meats is the best! Someone posted about terrible service. This only makes me believe they were a terrible customer! Everything I purchased there was superb! The best Pork Chops you can possibly get! Better than Berkshire! Steve is a great guy and always creates amazing roasts for me! He is very creative in all his meats!!
-
September 2023 by Lindsay Morgan
10/10 would recommend to a friend. I would eat marinated steak skewers everyday of the week if I could. Staff is very friendly!
-
September 2023 by Dennis Hart
I have been going here for years. Great meat and great service.
-
September 2023 by ann lombardo
Worst. I ordered days ahead and the surly man behind the counter kept shouting to the nice helper. The order was NOT as ordered. Not prepped as asked. Nasty service. Price high. I had to take the meat home and prepare it- butcher it- myself. Never go there. Mean and surly.
-
June 2023 by Juanita Billups
The owner was so nice. The store reminds me of a Mom and Pops store, he even offered me some of his delicious sausages to try, and they were delicious, I have to go back and buy some. The ground beef that I purchased was fresh and very good.
-
May 2023 by Gregory Tomao
This neighborhood shop is fantastic. Bob is so friendly and their meats and homemade pot pies and sides are awesome!
-
May 2023 by May Ignatius
This place is amazing, the meats are fantastic and the customer service is impeccable.
-
March 2023 by Michael C.
Knocked it out of the park!!! Having a butcher shop like this is an absolute gem. I reminder of how things used to be. Amazing staff and the best steaks I've ever cooked. Visited Peconic Prime Meats for my son's birthday dinner and they made me appear as a rockstar dad on the grill. Thank you!
-
November 2022 by Tina Toscano
Rude, nasty and unprofessional owner with no respect for clients !! Needs a lesson on how to speak to people in general!!!
-
November 2022 by Luis G Santos Rosales
Very good if you want to eat a good piece of meat ? they prepare it very well I recommend it ? ? ? ? ?
-
September 2022 by Kenny O liver
I have been going here since Steve opened a few years ago. Everything I have purchased from the homemade burgers, Sausages(variety of many flavors) twice baked potatoes and stuffed mushrooms are all delicious. You won’t be disappointed.
-
June 2022 by Em O.
My first instinct is to tell those who buy their meat from Citarella that they are fools... but if I say that I will have to wait in an even longer queue to get much better quality meat at a much lower price. So I will say nothing!
-
June 2022 by Angelina Zeppieri
Great selection of meat cuts and sausages
