-
April 2024 by Stefan Jaromsky
We went the night before the solar eclipse and it was absolute chaos. Had to wait an hour to be seated. Despite all of it, however, the service was great. Our server, Kris, was delightful. I just wish the drinks were a bit stronger.
-
April 2024 by Dennis DeYoung
Everyone will find something excellent for them on the menu!
-
April 2024 by Thomas Glossner
Well, if you've been following any of my other bar reviews, you know I'm not a high-end kind of guy. I wouldn't say Captain Jack's is a dive... It's just very comfortable. Come as you are. Not pretentious at all. Love that. That whole little area by the bay has just got a really nice vibe. It's a great place to sit outside during the boating season. I may be a little bit partial because I play music and I've had the opportunity to play there. So yeah, they sometimes have entertainment. That's always a lot of fun. I'm not sure who my waitress was, but the service was absolutely outstanding last visit. Didn't wait or want for anything. I was surprised at the prices. Cost me almost a hundred bucks for lunch. But I spared no expense on the 4 excellent Prison City IPA beers, and two fish fries were pretty good. That was 77 and I threw in a 20 tip. I haven't had any problem with the food quality; the last two times I've eaten there it was delicious. Lots of choices. It's a nice ride to Sodus Bay. Check it out.
-
March 2024 by Dan Argento
We tried it for the first time to celebrate Erica’s birthday and we got free wings and also she really enjoyed the buffalo cauliflower.. I had the fish fry one of the best I’ve ever had and overall the service was amazing and we had a corner booth to take everything in.. planning to come back at least by my birthday May17th.. Awsome place !
-
March 2024 by Becky Wyble
Stopped for lunch. We had a prime rib sandwich and a fish fry. They were delicious and the staff was very friendly. Service was good. There was lots of outdoor seating overlooking the water, but it was cold, so we will save that for another day!
-
March 2024 by Derek Yeakel
Price for plain pizza and an order of wings is ridiculous, $44 +. The pizza is an typical bar pizza and the wings are nothing special.
-
March 2024 by Linda Harper
Good food a little pricey but what isn't now days, excellent service, good time.
-
February 2024 by Rachel Bentley
Love it here. Delicious food, good atmosphere, beautiful scenery and lots of beer options. You can't go wrong.
-
February 2024 by Maxine Appleby
Really fun place- great beers on tap and delicious cheeseburgers and
-
February 2024 by Meta Tron
The food was sub par, they suffer from the same thing others do, price goes up food dish is smaller. I have been here a few times and I must say this time it was not worth the drive from Rochester. Do better! I love this place, don't "F" it up.
-
January 2024 by Cody Kahley
Under new management I believe. Prices jacked up, and the wings are nothing like it was before, and decor is changing. I regrettably wouldn’t recommend anymore sadly.
-
January 2024 by Justus Stephens
The food and service were amazing. Best wings I've had in a while and the waitress was great! Food was a little pricey and there was a musty smell. Otherwise, great
-
December 2023 by Sherrill Doremus
Great place! Delicious food, attentive service with a great atmosphere!!!
-
December 2023 by Michael Updyke
Went for a friends Birthday. Wings and other food we ordered were
-
December 2023 by Nicolas Isn
Lunch on the pontoon under a magnificent September sun. We had a great time there! Don't hesitate to take the typical dish from the bay, a treat but you have to be
