Hotels near Shelter Island, NY

11 locations found near Shelter Island

“Stayed for a long weekend break. It was great. Very peaceful with an excellent host, lovely room, wonderful breakfast and a gorgeous dog called Peaches who we loved spending time with. Can fully understand why they have many repeat visitors, we will certainly be backRooms: Well appointed, plenty of towels etc.”

5 Superb37 Reviews

“We've been going to the Bridgehampton Inn regularly for years now, because we love the ambiance, the very attentive service and the ever changing, very creative menu. This time they totally outdid themselves. BEST food I have had in the Hamptons all summer long. We had Tuna tartare (with Caviar!), sauteed foie gras, an amazing shrimp dish. Portions were beyond generous. Before leaving we even made a reservation for Labor Day weekend when we're entertaining friends we really want to impress! What a wonderful experience”

4.5 Superb185 Reviews

“The staff, service and food were absolutely on point.... oysters Rockefeller, the bone marrow and the lamb chops were a favorite among all our guests... Truly an amazing experience all the way around.... highly recommend the restaurant at the American Hotel in Sag Harbor.”

4.3 Superb251 Reviews

“Charming resort. Perfect getaway weekend with family just minutes from the ocean. Clean rooms, friendly staff and set in a great location minutes from town center.”

4.3 Superb80 Reviews

“I recently stayed at the Tapestry House for a girls overnight and thoroughly enjoyed my stay. Our host Joan, was lovely and extremely accommodating! The decor was beautiful and the house felt very welcoming. We really enjoyed sitting out on the front wrap around porch by the fire feature at night and while having breakfast. I’ll definitely be back!!Walkability: Many shops and restaurants in close proximity.Noteworthy details: Stunning trim work in every room. Beautiful high ceilings and lots of original details. Beautiful flowers adorn the porch.”

4.8 Superb19 Reviews

“Gorgeous little hotel, fantastic service, and a great area in Greenport! Felecia at the front desk is amazing. We loved raiding the galley late night and how most restaurants/bars were in walking distance. Visit Goldbergs in the AM for breakfast. Ten out of ten!”

4.3 Superb67 Reviews

“Gorgeous accommodations. So pretty, clean, nice pool and seating area. Complimentary coffee station in lobby (with actual good coffee!). Friendly staff! Loved it! Highly recommend staying here.”

4.3 Superb63 Reviews

“The staff here go above and beyond to cater to their guests. The staff makes you feel like family and it’s a special place. The rooms are spacious and well thought out and very conveniently located. I can’t wait to stay here again.”

3.8 Good76 Reviews

“we come by boat every year by boat for a couple of nights location is fabulous. Property is beautiful staffing owners very accommodating. Our bonus was concert on the lawn right behind our boat on Tuesday night. We had a wonderful time as always highly recommended.”

3.5 Good55 Reviews

“Absolutely lovely stay over Labor Day weekend with friends. We reserved a two bedroom suite that comfortably slept 5 of us and we were able to bring along our puppy! Breakfast was provided every morning including delicious donuts. The room, pool and grounds were very clean and well kept. The nearby beaches were lovely. We especially enjoyed spending time at the wineries and in the town of Greenport, which was only 5 minutes away by car. Lots of great restaurants and shops to explore and the views from the harbor were amazing!! Will definitely be back, thank you for a fantastic end-of-summer weekend!!”

2.4 Poor10 Reviews

“We Love Harbor Front inn. try to go every year atleast once. The hotel and services are 5 star. So convenient to all. Breakfast is perfect! Rooms are so comfortable!”

3.3 Good59 Reviews