Department Stores near Shelter Island, NY

5 locations found near Shelter Island

“Great store, has everything the family needed when on the island. We were out there and needed some beach chairs and ended up getting some souvenirs and some shirts for the kids.”

4.3 Superb8 Reviews

“Tried and true, not much has changed here in the 25 years of my stopping in. They've got a wide selection of pretty much everything you could need. Lots of vintage toys, puzzles, cool crafts, and the type of toys kids these days don't know exist.I had to buy a store t-shirt! They're simple and not in-your-face.”

4.5 Superb35 Reviews

“I love Tigmax. Every time you enter there is a new surprise. Brands at cheap prices. Really exciting. You just need patience to search. There is everything. clothing. footwear. Accessories and even toys and jewelry.”

4.4 Superb101 Reviews

“Not only is this the nicest HomeGoods I've been to, with carefully curated merchandise to suit the Hamptons vibe, but the staff is SUPER NICE, helpful and always welcoming. And dogs are welcome! I've found that other HomeGoods staff can be less than helpful and not so friendly. I always make the Wainscott store my go-to place !”

4.2 Good63 Reviews

“One of two Kmart locations left in the US (and the only regular location remaining -- the one in Miami was downsized to that of a drugstore size)

I will say the interior was severely dated. Lots of inventory that's been sitting for who knows how long. A few ceiling tiles were rotting. Some very dirty sections of floor in some spots of the store. Sounds negative, but I thought it was charming. Seemingly every Kmart I've been to throughout my life was like this. It made me feel nostalgic in a strange way.

Can't imagine how much longer this location will stay open, so I'm glad I visited when I did.”

3.8 Good136 Reviews